0x0b03485d0b03…0b03485a

ConfirmedInstitutional Markets765 vB67 sat/vB4 min decode

BlackRock funds hold 123,056 Strategy shares before MSCI exit

Three BlackRock funds reported 123,056 Strategy shares worth $13.74 million on Nov. 13, but fund documents show holdings, not forced sell orders, ahead of MSCI's Nov. 30 index removal.

BlackRock holds 123,056 Strategy shares ahead of MSCI exit, but how much must it sell?
WitnessBlackRock holds 123,056 Strategy shares ahead of MSCI exit, but how much must it sell?geralt / pixabay

Outputs

  1. Three BlackRock funds held 123,056 Strategy shares worth $13.74 million as of Nov. 13.

  2. MSCI removes Strategy from its USA Index at the Nov. 30 close, effective Dec. 1, under new non-operating company rules.

  3. MLRG holds 5,227 shares; URTH 29,345; ACWI 88,484 — all using representative sampling, not full replication.

  4. Strategy told MSCI's consultation that index-tracking funds hold about 13 million shares, 3.1% of basic shares outstanding.

  5. MSCI announces changes to derived indexes, including USXF's screened benchmark, on Nov. 18.

Three BlackRock funds reported 123,056 shares of Strategy, worth $13.74 million, on Nov. 13 — weeks before MSCI removes the company from its USA Index at the close of trading on Nov. 30. The holdings, drawn from published fund documents, show what these portfolios own today, not what they will sell when the deletion takes effect on Dec. 1.

MSCI applied new eligibility rules for companies it classifies as non-operating, and Strategy — Michael Saylor's Bitcoin-buying firm — was among the stocks selected for removal. The broader market expectation is selling: a fund that bought Strategy to track an index loses its reason to hold it once the stock drops out. But the structure of the affected funds complicates any simple estimate of forced supply.

What do the reported holdings show?

The iShares MSCI ACWI ETF, covering developed and emerging markets, held the largest position: 88,484 Strategy shares worth about $9.9 million on Nov. 13. The iShares MSCI World ETF (URTH) held 29,345 shares worth roughly $3.3 million. The iShares MSCI USA ETF (MLRG), which tracks the index Strategy is leaving directly, held only 5,227 shares, about $583,000.

Both URTH and ACWI include the US segment, so the MSCI USA deletion propagates into their benchmarks as well. All three funds use representative sampling — the manager selects a portfolio designed to behave like the index without owning every constituent at all times.

MLRG's prospectus says the fund intends to hold all or substantially all assets in index stocks at roughly index weights, and permits off-index positions around expected membership changes. The documents do not require the full 5,227 reported shares to be sold together at the Nov. 30 close.

Approximate Strategy exposure per $10,000 invested on Nov. 13:

  • USXF (screened MSCI USA): $12
  • MLRG (MSCI USA): $4
  • URTH (MSCI World): $3
  • ACWI (MSCI ACWI): $3

How does the swap-based fund differ?

BlackRock runs a second fund on the same index: the iShares MSCI USA Swap UCITS ETF, traded in Europe under symbols including MUSD. Rather than replicating the index stock for stock, it holds a separate developed-market portfolio and exchanges that portfolio's performance with financial institutions for the return of the MSCI USA Index through total return swaps.

When Strategy exits, it simply stops contributing to the index performance those contracts deliver. The fund documents do not establish whether MUSD's separate portfolio holds Strategy shares, or whether it will sell any. The swap counterparties may adjust their own hedges, and those trades are not disclosed — so multiplying MUSD's assets by Strategy's index weight produces no reliable sell estimate.

What remains unresolved?

The iShares ESG Advanced MSCI USA ETF (USXF) reported 16,144 Strategy shares on Nov. 13, but it tracks a screened version of MSCI USA. MSCI announces changes to those specialized, derived indexes on Nov. 18; as of Nov. 17, the treatment of USXF's benchmark remains pending, which is why its shares sit outside the three-fund subtotal.

In its response to MSCI's consultation, Strategy said funds tracking the provider's global investable indexes held about 13 million of its shares, or 3.1% of basic shares outstanding. That figure is far broader than the three-fund sample, but the statement names no individual funds and gives no observation date.

Holders tracking other indexes face no automatic change — Invesco QQQ, for example, follows the Nasdaq-100, which has its own provider and membership rules.

Can the sell-off actually be measured?

Daily holdings files will allow before-and-after comparisons once the changes land, but they carry limits. ETFs expand and contract with investor flows: a growing fund could hold more Strategy shares simply because it holds more of everything. Comparing Strategy shares against the fund's own share count separates growth from weight changes.

Stock can also exit through redemptions rather than exchange sales. Institutions can return ETF shares and receive underlying securities, so Strategy stock can leave a portfolio without the fund selling it — and the next holdings file records only the smaller position.

The business consequence is structural rather than mechanical. Strategy loses a place in the performance target these managers are paid to follow, which could weaken demand for its stock and make capital raises less attractive for a company that sells securities to finance Bitcoin purchases. The removal requires Strategy to sell no Bitcoin. The verifiable accounting begins after Dec. 1, when the next round of holdings files arrives and the Nov. 18 derived-index announcements settle USXF's status.

via cryptonews.net (Source)

More from Tom Whitfield

Tom Whitfield

Show full bio

News editor covering technology and product news in crypto and web3 industry at Mempool Brief.

1,374 articles