0x6ac84a3b6ac8…6ac84a3e

ConfirmedStablecoins596 vB169 sat/vB3 min decode

Coldcard Flaw Hit 0.17% of Users; Galaxy Estimates $116M Theft

Galaxy Research estimates 1,830 BTC, worth $116 million, were stolen through a Coldcard firmware flaw affecting about 0.17% of Coinkite users and prompting an Ontario class action.

Coinkite CEO says Coldcard flaw hit 0.17% of users as Galaxy tallies $116M in stolen Bitcoin
WitnessCoinkite CEO says Coldcard flaw hit 0.17% of users as Galaxy tallies $116M in stolen Bitcoingeralt / pixabay

Outputs

  1. Galaxy Research estimates the flaw led to the theft of 1,830 BTC, worth $116 million at the time.

  2. Coinkite CEO Rodolfo Novak says the flaw affected about 0.17% of the company's users.

  3. The flaw affected firmware versions 4.0.0 and 4.0.1, shipped in March 2021.

  4. Galaxy traced thefts across about 9,200 addresses from July 30 to Aug. 4, 2026.

  5. An Ontario class action filed Sept. 11, 2026, alleges inadequate warning despite notices dating to May 2025.

Galaxy Research estimates that a Coldcard firmware flaw led to the theft of about 1,830 BTC, worth an estimated $116 million at the time, after Coinkite CEO Rodolfo Novak said the issue affected roughly 0.17% of the company’s users.

The finding places a narrow user estimate beside a material loss for a hardware wallet built to keep Bitcoin out of hackers’ reach. Galaxy tracked the exploitation from July 30 through Aug. 4, 2026, across around 9,200 addresses. Coinkite began releasing emergency firmware patches on July 31, one day after the draining started.

What made the 2021 firmware vulnerable?

Galaxy traced the weakness to a March 2021 firmware update, versions 4.0.0 and 4.0.1. Under certain conditions, affected devices fell back on a weak software pseudorandom number generator when creating seeds, producing seeds with significantly reduced entropy.

Reduced entropy narrowed the pool of possible combinations enough for attackers to search it. Galaxy Research wrote in its findings: “Attackers could reconstruct affected seed phrases offline, without touching the device or tricking the owner into anything.” The flaw let attackers work from exposed seeds without interacting with the device or owner.

The July patch stops patched devices from generating weak seeds going forward. It cannot strengthen a seed that already exists. Users with compromised seeds must generate new ones and move their funds to the fresh wallets; updating the firmware alone leaves the old, guessable seed exactly where it was.

How did Coinkite estimate 0.17%?

Coinkite CEO Rodolfo Novak put the affected share at “about 0.17%,” according to the research findings. Coinkite derived that estimate from loss reports and internal production data. The figure remains an estimate, not a precise headcount, because the company’s privacy-focused design means it does not track who owns each wallet or how much it holds.

The public assessment therefore draws on two different lenses. Coinkite supplies an estimated share of users, while Galaxy supplies a blockchain-level tally of coins and addresses. Galaxy’s count measures visible losses; Novak’s percentage estimates exposure from reports and production data.

What does the Ontario class action test?

A class-action lawsuit filed in Ontario on Sept. 11, 2026, names Coinkite and its senior executives as defendants. It alleges that the company failed to adequately warn users despite internal notifications about the issue reportedly arriving as early as May 2025.

That alleged timeline would place more than one year between the early warnings and the start of the theft. No court has tested the allegations. The central issue is what Coinkite knew, when it knew it, and whether it told customers enough.

What must affected users do now?

Every owner whose seed was compromised remains exposed, regardless of which firmware version the device runs. The required action is to generate a new seed and move the funds. A patch can prevent future weak seed generation, but it cannot repair an existing exposed seed.

The research suggests the incident could dampen confidence in hardware wallets, particularly among self-custody advocates. It also points to potential regulatory interest in how wallet makers disclose vulnerabilities and protect user funds. For Coinkite, the immediate test is execution: every affected user who has not replaced the exposed seed still faces exposure.

What comes next?

The Ontario case is the next checkpoint: its handling of the alleged May 2025 warnings could establish a practical benchmark for vulnerability-disclosure windows across hardware wallets, although no hearing or ruling deadline was specified. Until affected owners replace compromised seeds, the exposure window also remains open.

via Crypto Briefing (Source)

More from Tom Whitfield

Tom Whitfield

Show full bio

News editor covering technology and product news in crypto and web3 industry at Mempool Brief.

1,374 articles