0x6c97aa2f6c97…6c97aa2c

ConfirmedRegulation & Policy579 vB173 sat/vB3 min decode

Dormant Bitcoin Wallet Moves After 15.8 Years, Undercutting $250 Billion Claim

A wallet funded at $0.90 in Feb. 2011 moved on Nov. 17 after 15.8 years, undermining a New York suit claiming title over $250 billion in dormant BTC.

Satoshi-Era Bitcoin Holder Wakes Up After 15 Years, Refuting $250 Billion ‘Lost’ Claim
WitnessSatoshi-Era Bitcoin Holder Wakes Up After 15 Years, Refuting $250 Billion ‘Lost’ Claimlukasbieri / pixabay

Outputs

  1. Address 1ALpEWtXApR19hLXvcG8NfkPyGsUMhFPMS moved coins on Nov. 17 in block 976,209 after 15.8 years, paying a 399-satoshi fee (~26 cents).

  2. The wallet was funded Feb. 8, 2011, when BTC traded near $0.90, yielding a paper gain above 7,000,000%.

  3. The 'Noah Doe' lawsuit targets 39,069 dormant wallets holding ~3.8 million BTC, valued around $250 billion.

  4. At a Sept. 8 hearing, the Bitcoin Policy Institute sought to intervene as defendant and The Digital Chamber as amicus curiae.

A Bitcoin address funded in February 2011, when BTC traded near $0.90, moved its coins for the first time on Nov. 17 in block 976,209 — directly undercutting a lawsuit that seeks title over billions of dollars in supposedly abandoned wallets. Galaxy Research analysts traced the transfer from address 1ALpEWtXApR19hLXvcG8NfkPyGsUMhFPMS to an unknown destination, paid with a 399-satoshi fee, roughly 26 cents, on a position carrying a paper gain above 7,000,000%.

The wallet sat untouched for 15.8 years. On-chain databases label it "Noah Doe #3409 (Salomon Client Dusted)," and that label is how it landed among the defendants in ABC Company, XYZ Company, and Noah Doe v. John Does 1–39,069.

What is the lawsuit claiming?

An anonymous plaintiff using the pseudonym Noah Doe and two companies want the rights to 39,069 Bitcoin wallets that have not moved coins in more than five years. The plaintiffs say those wallets hold roughly 3.8 million BTC — about $250 billion at current prices.

They filed under Article 7-B of New York's Personal Property Law, the state's lost-and-found statute. Under that law, a finder must hand lost property to the police, and the property belongs to the finder if the owner doesn't claim it within the statutory window. The plaintiffs valued each address at less than $10, which they argued triggers a one-year waiting period.

Their method was mechanical. They used an algorithm to "find" dormant addresses, saved them onto USB flash drives and delivered them to the New York Police Department. They then served the wallet owners on the blockchain itself — via microtransactions with embedded messages using OP_RETURN, a practice known as "dusting." The campaign is tied to Salomon Brothers Strategic Advisors. Once the waiting period lapsed, the plaintiffs asked the court to recognize the coins as theirs.

Who is pushing back?

The case has been stayed repeatedly amid motions to dismiss and amicus briefs. At a Sept. 8 hearing, the Bitcoin Policy Institute asked to intervene as a defendant, and The Digital Chamber asked to join as amicus curiae. Galaxy Research characterized the dispute as a case "in which anonymous plaintiffs are seeking to claim legal title over Satoshi's coins."

Will Owens of Galaxy Research, who attended the hearing, said The Digital Chamber's arguments were "well pleaded" and that "the judge sounded sympathetic to them."

Critics of the suit argue Article 7-B was written for physical property you can pick up and hand to police for safekeeping — not for blockchain records where the "finder" holds no private keys. In September, Galaxy's head of research, Alex Thorn, said the lost-property law includes "protection from 'Noah Doe-style' dormancy attacks on legal ownership."

What does the Nov. 17 transfer change?

The movement from a wallet dormant since Feb. 8, 2011 — before the first major exchanges, before institutional custody — shows the underlying assumption of the suit is fragile: an address that looks abandoned may simply have an owner with a very long time horizon. Activity on-chain, not algorithmic labeling, is what demonstrates control.

The transfer also costs the plaintiffs part of their claimed inventory. One of the 39,069 target wallets has now demonstrably moved, with the owner paying fractions of a dollar to do it.

The court still has motions to dismiss and the intervention requests to resolve, and the Sept. 8 hearing suggests judicial sympathy is running against the plaintiffs.

via cryptonews.net (Source)

More from Daniel Okafor

Daniel Okafor

Show full bio

Correspondent covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in crypto and web3 industry at Mempool Brief.

1,514 articles