1c91e1cc-6

ConfirmedSecurity529 words3 min decode

Phylax transaction filter tests Ethereum’s censorship limits

Ethereum’s new DeFi security tool raises questions over censorship
WitnessEthereum’s new DeFi security tool raises questions over censorshipWorldSpectrum / pixabay

Phylax’s Nov. 10 integration with Titan Builder can exclude harmful Ethereum transactions before settlement, according to Phylax, which says its builder produces one in every two Ethereum blocks.

The system gives DeFi applications a way to impose transaction-level circuit breakers. It also creates a freeze risk that protocol designers will have to manage. Founder and CEO Odysseas Lamtzidis said: “The sane default we provide and suggest to protocols is a fail-open behavior.”

How does the filter work?

Announced on Nov. 10, the integration lets applications define rules during block construction, which Titan checks against candidate transactions before including them in a proposed Ethereum block.

Phylax says this can prevent exploits from settling. The company contrasts that approach with monitoring systems and emergency interventions that begin only after an attack. The proposal could also bolster defenses against North Korean hackers and U.S.-sanctioned actors. Its stated mission is to stop users losing money to hacks and DeFi errors.

In a blog, Phylax imagined a vulnerable vault mistakenly releasing $1 million to a user whose shares were worth $1,000. A circuit breaker could cap the amount leaving the vault in one transaction, preventing the funds from being drained.

The post cited the $6.3 billion Binance hack and the $380 million Bitget exploit as examples of losses similar safeguards might limit. In those attacks, malicious actors drained exchange wallets and moved large amounts of crypto through decentralized protocols.

Can the system freeze DeFi?

Digital assets lawyer Gabriel Shapiro sees a different risk. Smart contracts can reject transactions unless builders supply required security attestations. Such a setup can leave protected functions rejecting transactions indefinitely while builders withhold the attestations required for inclusion, restoring service only when those builders resume.

That fail-open setting lets transactions through when the security checks are unavailable. It remains optional, leaving each protocol to weigh security against liveness, meaning continued availability. Protocols can also decide whether their smart contracts remain immutable or can be changed through governance.

Shapiro would make fail-open mandatory. He also wants time delays on changes to the safeguards, preventing protocols from removing protections immediately.

Does filtering strengthen Ethereum’s builders?

Ethereum researcher Fan Zhang said the design became practical because block production already sits with a concentrated group of builders. He described the approach as appealing, especially as AI bots find bugs faster.

Zhang warned that additional code at such a critical point in transaction processing creates new failure modes. These include implementation errors and the theft, loss or impersonation of builder signing keys. He also worries efforts to decentralize builders could undermine one another.

Ethereum researcher Sen Yang said major protocols relying on a small number of builders for security enforcement could give those builders a competitive advantage. That reliance could further worsen market concentration, he said.

Ethereum’s proposed enshrined proposer-builder separation, or ePBS, is slated for the upcoming Glamsterdam upgrade. Yang said it may reduce reliance on third-party relays, but it does not directly address builder concentration.

Transactions excluded by dominant builders could still enter blocks through non-censoring builders. The likely result would be delays rather than permanent exclusion, Yang said.

via ieeexplore.ieee.org (Original)

More from Marcus Bennett

Marcus Bennett

Show full bio

Senior reporter covering money, funding and market shifts around crypto and web3 industry at Mempool Brief.

1,512 articles