0x4e60872d4e60…4e60872a

ConfirmedRegulation & Policy588 vB135 sat/vB3 min decode

SEC and CFTC Left With Three Commissioners as Peirce Exits

Hester Peirce's Friday exit leaves the SEC with two commissioners and the CFTC with one, draining seven seats as crypto rulemaking proceeds without the CLARITY Act.

Crypto regulation at SEC, CFTC to come down to 3 commissioners following key resignation
WitnessCrypto regulation at SEC, CFTC to come down to 3 commissioners following key resignationAI-generated

Outputs

  1. Hester Peirce leaves the SEC on Friday after eight years, about two months before her second term's 18-month extension ends

  2. Seven commissioner seats at the SEC and CFTC will be empty, leaving Atkins, Uyeda and Selig as the only commissioners overseeing crypto markets

  3. The CLARITY Act failed in the Republican-controlled Senate, leaving both agencies to regulate digital assets through guidance rather than legislation

Hester Peirce leaves the US Securities and Exchange Commission on Friday, roughly two months before the end of an 18-month extension to her second term, reducing the agency to two sitting commissioners and leaving just three commissioners across the SEC and CFTC to oversee a $3 trillion crypto industry.

Peirce served eight years at the SEC and built a reputation in the digital asset sector as "Crypto Mom" for her consistent criticism of enforcement-heavy crypto policy. Her departure marks only the second time in US history that the SEC has operated with two commissioners. Chair Paul Atkins and Mark Uyeda, both Republicans, remain the sole members of a panel that statute expects to hold five seats across party lines.

The Commodity Futures Trading Commission is in even thinner shape. Chair Michael Selig has run the agency as its only commissioner since December 2025, when acting chair Caroline Pham departed. After Friday, seven commissioner seats across the two agencies will be vacant.

Under federal law, President Donald Trump is the only official who can nominate replacements for the empty seats. The White House has announced no nominations so far. A White House official said Trump intends to nominate members to both agencies "in the near future." A CNBC report from Sept. 4 said administration officials had been vetting four candidates for the vacant CFTC commissioner seats, though no names have surfaced. Cointelegraph contacted the SEC and CFTC for comment on potential nominations but received no immediate response.

All current appointees except Uyeda, a 2022 Biden pick, were chosen by Trump. That consolidation has drawn pushback from Capitol Hill. "Congress designed these boards and commissions to be bipartisan and gave them the authority to regulate some of the most vital and significant parts of American life," Senate Democrats wrote in a June letter to Trump and Senate Majority Leader John Thune, citing the SEC, CFTC and other departments. "But the Trump Administration appears intent on ensuring that it retains complete control over these agencies, with little interest in working in good faith with Congress."

The staffing gap arrives at a moment when both agencies are carrying the weight of crypto policy without legislation. The Digital Asset Clarity (CLARITY) Act, which the industry had pushed lawmakers to pass earlier this month, failed in the Republican-controlled Senate. The bill would have shifted significant digital asset oversight from the SEC to the CFTC and, in the view of many market participants, settled long-running jurisdictional disputes between the two regulators.

In the absence of statutory reform, the agencies are proceeding through rulemaking and guidance. The SEC has issued staff guidance on investment contracts as applied to token issuers, while the CFTC has specified how companies could use blockchain recordkeeping — two parallel interpretive tracks that diverge in approach and leave issuers navigating overlapping federal frameworks without congressional direction.

The operational consequences are concrete. Commissions designed to act with quorum and bipartisan balance now run on minimal staffing, which slows rulemaking cycles, concentrates agenda-setting power in a single chair at each agency, and raises legal durability questions for rules passed on two-member votes. Any future commissioner confirmations would require Senate approval, a process that has historically taken months.

The immediate question is timing. Until the White House sends nominations to the Senate, Atkins and Uyeda will steer SEC policy alone and Selig will continue to run the CFTC single-handedly — an arrangement that will shape how both agencies interpret digital asset law heading into the next rulemaking and enforcement cycle.

via cnbc.com (Original)

More from Nathan Brooks

Nathan Brooks

Show full bio

Market editor covering business strategy at Mempool Brief.

451 articles