0x0a335c440a33…0a335c47

ConfirmedRegulation & Policy818 vB16 sat/vB4 min decode

Vitalik Buterin Urges Canadians to Fight Bill C-22 Encryption Rules

Vitalik Buterin urged Canadians to contact senators over Bill C-22, calling it Canada's version of the EU Chat Control debate as the Senate committee reviews the encryption bill.

Ethereum Co-Founder Vitalik Buterin Urges Canadians to Oppose Bill C-22
WitnessEthereum Co-Founder Vitalik Buterin Urges Canadians to Oppose Bill C-22AI-generated

Outputs

  1. Buterin urged Canadians on November 17 to oppose Bill C-22, comparing it to the EU's Chat Control debate.

  2. The House of Commons passed the bill on June 18, 2026; the Senate referred it to committee on October 22.

  3. Core providers could face metadata retention mandates of up to six months under future regulations.

  4. Privacy Commissioner Philippe Dufresne called for amendments in a November 2 statement to senators.

  5. The UN Human Rights Office said on November 3 the bill threatens to undermine end-to-end encryption.

Ethereum co-founder Vitalik Buterin has urged Canadians to contact their senators and oppose Bill C-22, calling the proposed lawful access legislation Canada's version of the European Union's "Chat Control" controversy.

In a November 17 post on X, Buterin wrote that "Canada is going through its own version of the Chat Control mess with the C-22 bill." He asked Canadians to support "backdoor-free, no asterisks" end-to-end encryption, which he described as important to a "secure, free and open society." He also urged governments to "minimize all backdoors and mass data collection" as artificial intelligence reshapes cybersecurity risk, and linked to an October 8 Mozilla paper on the bill's impact on encryption.

Where does Bill C-22 stand in Parliament?

The Lawful Access Act, 2026 has not become law. The House of Commons passed it on June 18, and the Senate approved second reading on October 22 before referring it to the Standing Senate Committee on National Security, Defence and Veterans Affairs. A November 16 committee hearing heard testimony from Meta, Signal, privacy advocates and legal experts. Report stage, third reading and royal assent remain pending.

Part 2 of the bill would let the government require providers to develop and maintain technical capabilities for lawful access, though an order itself does not grant access to data.

What does the bill require of service providers?

The legislation defines electronic service providers broadly: organizations that create, store, process, transmit, receive or make electronic information available, provided they serve people in Canada or do business there. It does not name crypto exchanges, wallet providers or self-custody apps.

Key elements of the House-passed text include:

  • A decryption clause stating the act cannot force a provider to decrypt customer-encrypted information, or ensure authorities can decrypt it, unless the provider supplied the encryption and holds the information needed to unlock it.
  • No requirement to implement technical obligations that would introduce a systemic vulnerability or prevent fixing one. The definition of systemic vulnerability excludes risks tied only to people covered by a warrant or other legal authority.
  • A blank core-provider schedule, to be filled by future regulations. Core providers could be required to retain specified metadata for up to six months, including the date, time, duration, origin and destination of an exchange. The bill excludes retention of message content, web-browsing history or social media activity.

The public safety minister could issue orders to any electronic service provider, including those outside the core-provider category. Such orders could impose the same technical and metadata obligations, last up to two years, and require approval from the Intelligence Commissioner. Providers must have an opportunity to make representations, though the legislation restricts disclosure of the orders.

Could crypto wallets fall under the law?

Some crypto businesses could qualify under the broad provider definition. A centralized exchange or hosted wallet serving Canadians may fall within scope if it stores account details or processes customer transactions. The text does not expressly list exchanges or wallet apps, and it does not require self-custody developers to hold users' private keys. The decryption clause protects customer-encrypted information when a provider lacks the necessary key, so whether a particular wallet developer or privacy tool qualifies depends on how its service operates.

Ottawa maintains that investigators still need legal authorization to obtain personal information and that the bill grants no direct access to company systems.

What have privacy advocates and watchdogs said?

Mozilla argued in its October paper that "there is no safe way to create exceptional access to encrypted data that only the intended actor can use." It warned that companies could be required to build capabilities that bypass existing protections or access data before encryption.

Privacy Commissioner Philippe Dufresne told senators in a November 2 statement that he welcomed amendments that "preclude requirements to decrypt end-to-end encrypted information," while calling for clearer limits on subscriber information and a requirement that obligations be necessary and proportionate. The UN Human Rights Office said in November 3 comments that Bill C-22 "threatens to undermine end-to-end encryption" and recommended an explicit provision protecting critical technical safeguards. The Canadian Civil Liberties Association has cited the UN comments in its call for amendments.

The EU comparison has limits. The bloc's long-term child sexual abuse proposal concerns detecting and reporting abuse material, including disputed scanning of private communications, and talks remain unresolved. A separate temporary EU measure allowing voluntary detection runs until April 3, 2028 and excludes end-to-end encrypted communications, according to the Council of the EU.

Buterin has backed privacy tooling before: the Ethereum Foundation supports default wallet privacy through its Kohaku software development kit, and in December 2025 he allocated 256 ETH to Session and SimpleX Chat. The Senate committee must still report the bill back before report stage, third reading and royal assent can proceed.

via crypto.news (Source)

More from Tom Whitfield

Tom Whitfield

Show full bio

News editor covering technology and product news in crypto and web3 industry at Mempool Brief.

1,374 articles