07766536-2
Fourth Circuit backs Maryland’s authority over Kalshi in 2-1 ruling
The Fourth Circuit ruled 2-1 that Maryland can regulate Kalshi, putting state oversight ahead in three of four appellate decisions while a CFTC deadline tests nationwide market access.

Outputs
The Fourth Circuit ruled 2-1 on Wednesday for Maryland’s authority over Kalshi.
Three of four federal appellate decisions in the prediction-market disputes favor state oversight.
The CFTC set a 30-day deadline for regulated exchanges to offer contracts in all 50 states.
The deadline covers operators including Kalshi, Polymarket and Coinbase.
By Marcus Bennett
Three of four federal appellate decisions involving U.S. prediction markets now favor state oversight, after the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit ruled 2-1 on Wednesday that Maryland may regulate Kalshi under its sports-wagering laws.
The appeals court agreed with lower-court rulings that Maryland retains authority over gambling regulation. Judge Roger Gregory said Congress had not clearly displaced the state’s concurrent authority because gambling regulation has long rested within traditional state police powers.
The decision gives Maryland a firmer legal basis for applying sportsbook-style licensing and consumer protections to Kalshi. It does not settle the wider dispute over federal preemption, but it adds another appellate vote for state control.
What does this change for Kalshi?
In a Wednesday statement, Maryland Attorney General Anthony Brown said: “Kalshi must meet the same consumer protection standards as every other sportsbook serving Maryland residents.” He said Maryland’s licensing laws require sportsbooks to:
- Safeguard customer data.
- Refrain from deceptive advertising.
- Stop marketing to people barred from betting or at risk of gambling harm.
Brown also said federal commodities rules were never designed to provide those safeguards. For Kalshi, that turns an abstract jurisdictional dispute into specific duties around customer information, advertising and marketing.
The ruling adds compliance pressure to Kalshi’s operations in Maryland. It also supports the state’s broader argument that federal commodities regulation cannot supply every protection that local gambling rules require.
The CFTC deadline creates a conflicting choice
At the same time, a 30-day deadline is approaching for a U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission demand that regulated exchanges return to offering contracts in all 50 states. The demand rejects individual state geographical restrictions, even where states have ordered prediction markets to halt.
The demand reaches beyond Kalshi. Regulated prediction-market operators cited in the dispute include Kalshi, Polymarket, Coinbase and other operators. For them, the federal instruction and state court orders now point in opposite directions.
The choice carries immediate legal risk. If the exchanges comply, they could defy the state court orders limiting or stopping their operations. If they refuse, they may run afoul of their federal regulator.
That leaves prediction markets in a fragmented compliance structure. Operators must reconcile federal preemption, state licensing requirements and court-issued restrictions before deciding where and how to offer event contracts.
Kalshi points to a divided judiciary
Kalshi is framing the cases as conflicting rather than as a series of losses. A company spokeswoman said: “Judges can’t agree with each other on why we’re wrong.” She added that the splintered decision, including three separate contradictory opinions, demonstrated there was no unified, coherent legal argument against prediction markets.
The company is using that split to resist the tide of state enforcement. Three of the four appellate decisions favor state oversight, even though the judges do not offer one consistent rationale. That mismatch gives operators room to argue that the outcomes conflict.
Unless the U.S. Supreme Court resolves the disagreement, different lower courts and appellate panels could continue producing different results for similar prediction-market operations. Businesses must plan for state-by-state rules until a higher court supplies a binding answer.
The next concrete test arrives when the CFTC’s 30-day window closes: compliance could put prediction-market exchanges in direct conflict with state court orders, while refusal could expose them to enforcement by their federal regulator.
via cryptonews.net (Source)
More from Marcus Bennett
Show full bio
Senior reporter covering money, funding and market shifts around crypto and web3 industry at Mempool Brief.
1,512 articles