bf78845a-e
Fourth Circuit Rules Maryland Can Regulate Kalshi Sports Contracts
A 2-1 Fourth Circuit panel says Maryland can apply its sports betting laws to Kalshi, the third of four appeals courts to back state authority over prediction markets.

Outputs
Fourth Circuit ruled 2-1 on Wednesday that Maryland can apply sports betting laws to Kalshi's sports contracts.
Three of four federal appeals courts to rule on the issue now support state regulation of prediction markets.
Maryland AG Anthony Brown said Kalshi must meet the same consumer protection standards as other sports betting platforms.
The CFTC directed Kalshi, Polymarket, Coinbase and other regulated platforms to restore service in all 50 states within 30 days.
A divided federal appeals court ruled Wednesday that Maryland can apply its sports betting laws to Kalshi's sports contracts, making the Fourth Circuit the third of four federal appeals courts to side with states in the widening fight over prediction-market regulation.
The panel split 2-1. The decision concerns Kalshi's sports contracts specifically and Maryland law specifically, but its weight extends well past one platform in one state. With the Fourth Circuit joining the majority trend, federal appeals courts have now ruled on state authority over prediction markets four times, and state regulators have won three of those cases.
What did Maryland's attorney general say?
Maryland Attorney General Anthony Brown said Kalshi must meet the same consumer protection standards as any other sports betting platform operating in the state. That framing matters: Maryland isn't treating Kalshi's sports contracts as novel financial instruments, but as sports wagering, full stop, with the licensing and consumer-protection obligations that follow.
Kalshi pushed back on the reading. The company said the appellate decisions are divided and have not established a consistent legal basis for state oversight of its products. That's not an unreasonable position on the numbers alone — one federal appeals court has gone the other way — and it points toward eventual Supreme Court review as the circuit split hardens.
Where does this leave the CFTC conflict?
The ruling lands on top of an already tense federal-state standoff over where prediction markets may legally operate. The Commodity Futures Trading Commission previously directed Kalshi, Polymarket, Coinbase and other regulated platforms to restore service in all 50 states within 30 days.
That directive now collides directly with rulings like this one. If a platform complies with the CFTC and offers sports contracts in Maryland, it risks violating state law and a court order backing that law. If it keeps state restrictions in place, it sits at odds with its federal regulator. Platforms are caught between two commands that cannot both be satisfied cleanly.
What are the operational consequences?
For Kalshi, the immediate consequence is regulatory exposure in Maryland unless it obtains a sports wagering license or wins relief on appeal. For Polymarket, Coinbase and other platforms watching from the sidelines, the Fourth Circuit decision raises the cost of the CFTC's 30-day nationwide-restore directive in any state with an active enforcement posture.
For state regulators, the decision is a third appellate datapoint supporting the view that sports-event contracts offered to retail customers are gambling products subject to state police powers, not purely derivatives under exclusive federal jurisdiction.
What comes next?
The circuit split is now the story. Kalshi's argument that the decisions lack a consistent legal basis is effectively a petition roadmap, and the Supreme Court will likely have to resolve whether prediction-market sports contracts answer to state gaming law or to the CFTC alone. Until then, platforms face a patchwork where each new appellate ruling — and each CFTC deadline — narrows the space where both regulators can be obeyed at once.
via tokenpost.com (Source)
More from Daniel Okafor
Show full bio
Correspondent covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in crypto and web3 industry at Mempool Brief.
1,653 articles