0x150188cf1501…150188d2

ConfirmedRegulation & Policy788 vB25 sat/vB4 min decode

Hyperliquid Policy Center backs two CFTC contract actions

Hyperliquid Policy Center urged the CFTC to preserve its gambling exclusion and clarify event-contract oversight as Louisiana became the agency's 12th state lawsuit, widening jurisdictional conflict.

Hyperliquid backs 2 CFTC rules as states fight prediction markets
WitnessHyperliquid backs 2 CFTC rules as states fight prediction markets3844328 / pixabay

Outputs

  1. Nov. 16: Hyperliquid Policy Center submitted two letters supporting the CFTC's gambling exclusion and event-contract framework.

  2. Oct. 19: The gambling exclusion took effect as an interim final rule; the companion event-contract rule remains a proposal.

  3. Nov. 13: The CFTC sued Louisiana, its 12th state lawsuit, after an order targeting more than 30 derivatives companies.

  4. Nov. 18: Public comments on both CFTC rulemaking actions are due.

  5. HIP-4's initial recurring Bitcoin binary settles daily at 06:00 UTC.

By Tom Whitfield

Public comments on two CFTC actions involving event contracts and casino-style gambling are due Nov. 18, after the Hyperliquid Policy Center submitted letters on Nov. 16. Signed by CEO Jake Chervinsky and senior counsel Brad Bourque, the filings support federal oversight of event contracts and preserve the exclusion for licensed gambling products.

HPC describes itself as an independent research and advocacy organization. Its filings support a national framework separating exchange-traded derivatives from wagers offered by state- or tribal-licensed gambling operators.

What rules are in play?

  • Gambling exclusion: Published and effective Oct. 19 as an interim final rule, it excludes qualifying sportsbook wagers and casino games from the definition of a swap, one of the CFTC’s main derivatives categories.
  • Event-contract proposal: The companion measure would expressly include contracts tied to sports, politics, culture and weather in the swap definition. It remains a proposal, not a final rule.

The distinction rests on market structure. The CFTC separates bets placed against a house from contracts traded between participants at market prices. Registered exchanges collect transaction fees regardless of the outcome, while the contracts pass through a registered clearinghouse.

HPC says an event-contract holder can sell or close a position before settlement. A wager remains between the customer and the house until the event ends. The group argues that similar payouts do not require identical regulation.

Why does HPC support the exclusion?

In its gambling-rule submission, HPC wrote, “HPC supports the Interim Final Rule without qualification,” and urged the commission to retain the rule text unchanged. It cites insurance policies and credit default swaps as products that can offer similar protection while operating under different legal frameworks.

The group also seeks a cross-reference between the two actions. It says the CFTC’s explanatory text already makes the distinction, but wants the proposed regulatory text to state it directly.

How would HPC limit state-law claims?

HPC wants the CFTC to confirm that applicable state or tribal law means the law of the jurisdiction licensing a gambling operator. It opposes applying the most restrictive gambling law from elsewhere in the country.

The organization further argues that calling an exchange-traded contract a wager under state law should not bring it within the exclusion. It also wants privately negotiated event-based swaps protected from the same argument.

On terminology, HPC recommends defining event contracts through statutory language covering payments tied to an occurrence or contingency. That would distinguish them from derivatives based on changes in commodity prices.

HPC traces the jurisdictional dispute to state laws treating futures as gambling in the 1880s. It says Congress later separated designated exchanges from bucket shops, where operators assumed the risk of customers’ trades, and preserved that division in subsequent derivatives laws.

What does the Louisiana and Arkansas litigation change?

On Nov. 13, the CFTC said it had sued Louisiana after the state secured an order targeting more than 30 companies involved in federally regulated derivatives trading. Louisiana became the 12th state the agency had sued to defend its exclusive jurisdiction.

The Louisiana suit seeks to stop state restrictions on registered exchanges, brokers and clearing organizations. It places the event-contract framework within a broader conflict over whether states can regulate federally registered derivatives businesses.

Arkansas is the CFTC’s 11th state lawsuit, according to the commission’s Nov. 13 statement. Its separate case challenges state enforcement against Kalshi; Arkansas alleges illegal gambling and deceptive business practices, while federal authorities say the disputed transactions fall within CFTC authority.

Arkansas also sought civil penalties potentially reaching hundreds of millions of dollars against registered exchanges. The two cases show how CFTC rules intersect with state assertions of exclusive gambling and derivatives jurisdiction, rather than merely defining a federal product category.

How does Hyperliquid already support outcome contracts?

Hyperliquid’s documentation describes HIP-4 as a framework for fully collateralized outcome contracts that operate without leverage or liquidations. Its initial market is a recurring Bitcoin binary settling daily at 06:00 UTC, with linked Yes and No tokens whose order books share liquidity.

An August report documented OUT’s deployment through HIP-4. The timeline shows that event-based trading on Hyperliquid predates the latest policy letters, separating an operating protocol from unresolved federal and state rules.

What regulated market structure is emerging?

A separate U.S. access initiative involves Payward’s proposed regulated markets using Hyperliquid’s HIP-3 infrastructure. In an Oct. 26 outline, Bitnomial would create and administer the perpetual futures markets, while NinjaTrader Clearing would carry customer accounts, subject to regulatory approval.

The next dated milestone is the Nov. 18 comment deadline; the event-contract proposal remains nonfinal while state challenges to CFTC jurisdiction stay active.

via crypto.news (Source)

More from Tom Whitfield

Tom Whitfield

Show full bio

News editor covering technology and product news in crypto and web3 industry at Mempool Brief.

1,374 articles