0x0199f2210199…0199f21e
Hyperliquid Policy Center Presses CFTC to Finalize Gambling Exclusion Rule
The Hyperliquid Policy Center wants the CFTC to keep its gambling-exclusion rule as written, clarify which state law governs, and define event contracts as circuit courts split over Kalshi.

Outputs
The Hyperliquid Policy Center filed comments with the CFTC on November 16 asking it to keep the October 19 interim final rule unchanged.
The CFTC rule excludes casino-style gambling products from the swap definition and took effect immediately on Federal Register publication.
The Hyper Foundation backed the Policy Center's launch with 1 million HYPE tokens.
Kalshi has won one of three federal appeals; the Third Circuit sided with it 2-1 against New Jersey in April.
New Jersey AG Jennifer Davenport asked the U.S. Supreme Court on September 2 to review the Third Circuit ruling.
The Hyperliquid Policy Center asked the CFTC on November 16 to keep its interim final rule excluding casino-style gambling products from the legal definition of a "swap" exactly as written — and to clarify several points that could shape how prediction markets reach U.S. users.
The CFTC released the interim final rule on October 19. It keeps sportsbook bets and casino games outside the swap definition and took legal effect immediately upon publication in the Federal Register, even though the agency opened a 30-day public comment window. CFTC Chairman Michael Selig said at the time that casino-style gambling products are not derivatives.
The same day, the agency introduced a second, proposed rule that would bring event contracts on sports, politics, culture and weather inside the swap definition.
What does the Policy Center want changed?
The group's comment letter makes four concrete requests:
- The CFTC should confirm that "applicable State or Tribal law" specifically means the law of the state or tribe that licensed the operator.
- A state should not be able to pull a contract traded on a federally registered market into the gambling exclusion simply by labeling it a bet.
- The agency should adopt a definition of "event contract" drawn from the Commodity Exchange Act, along with a short list of traits that mark a product as gambling.
- The CFTC should restate that it had "good cause" to skip the public comment period before the interim rule took effect.
The Policy Center also wants the agency to explain publicly how the rule works, arguing clarity serves market participants.
Why does the rule matter to Hyperliquid?
The Policy Center describes itself as independent. Its launch, however, was backed with 1 million of Hyperliquid's HYPE tokens from the Hyper Foundation, the organization that supports the Hyperliquid network.
Hyperliquid runs its own prediction markets on-chain. Validators — the network of computers that process and confirm transactions — operate those markets under an upgrade called HIP-4. None of these markets are listed on an exchange registered with the CFTC.
The Hyperliquid group says it wants to help Americans access these markets legally. Its letters to the commission could therefore be a first step toward Hyperliquid entering the U.S. market, where its current on-chain prediction products sit outside the regulated perimeter.
Why is the rule controversial?
The CFTC's exclusion took legal force on day one while comments were still open, and asking the agency to lock it in now means drawing a boundary while the courts are still fighting over where prediction markets sit under federal and state law.
Those fights are far from settled. Kalshi, a prediction market platform, has won one of its three federal appeals so far:
- The Third Circuit sided with Kalshi 2-1 against New Jersey in April.
- The Ninth Circuit ruled against the company in a Nevada case on August 28.
- In September, the Sixth Circuit ruled that Ohio and Tennessee can enforce their sports-betting laws against Kalshi.
A Maryland appeal is still pending before the Fourth Circuit, and New Jersey Attorney General Jennifer Davenport petitioned the U.S. Supreme Court on September 2 to review the Third Circuit decision.
The CFTC, where Michael Selig is currently the only sitting commissioner, claims exclusive authority over prediction markets. In May it filed a brief backing Kalshi in the Ohio appeal. More than a dozen states have taken enforcement action against Kalshi or sued it over its sports contracts.
The Policy Center acknowledged the judicial disagreement in a blog post. It warned that the states' approach could let any state treat a contract on crops, energy or currencies as gambling based only on what the contract refers to — a framing with direct operational consequences for commodity and derivatives markets, not just sports prediction products.
What happens next?
The CFTC must still decide whether to finalize the gambling exclusion as written or revise it after reviewing comments. A final rule that adopts the Policy Center's requested clarifications — particularly on which state's law governs and what counts as an "event contract" — would materially narrow the grounds on which state regulators can reach federally registered markets, while the pending circuit splits and the New Jersey Supreme Court petition keep the question alive in the courts.
via cryptonews.net (Source)
More from Daniel Okafor
Show full bio
Correspondent covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in crypto and web3 industry at Mempool Brief.
1,514 articles