0x36a0598436a0…36a05981
ZachXBT Disputes $3M Gate.io Freeze, Citing Alleged Tracing Error
ZachXBT says a $3M Gate.io freeze in India rests on a tracing error, pairing Merlin Chain hashes with OKX and Binance sources. Gate disputes the route.

Outputs
ZachXBT tied three Merlin Chain withdrawals of ~10.1367, 4.907 and 9.9795 BTC (March–June 2025) to the disputed $3M Gate.io freeze
Gate.io received the freeze request in September 2025; police said in September 2026 the case remains under court review
Gate disputes the tracing, has not handed over assets, and says only the investor can challenge the order in court
The investor separately lost 7 BTC in a July 15, 2025 private-key compromise, reported to police with SlowMist engaged
Indian crypto gains face a 30% tax under Section 115BBH and 1% TDS under Section 194S
A $3 million freeze at Gate.io is now the center of a very public tracing dispute. On-chain investigator ZachXBT says Indian authorities locked the wrong account, and he brought transaction hashes to prove it.
The numbers are specific. ZachXBT paired three withdrawals from Merlin Chain — Bitcoin's layer-2 — with payouts of roughly 10.1367 BTC, 4.907 BTC, and 9.9795 BTC in March, May, and June 2025. His argument is simple: the funds police traced to a Gate account actually originated at OKX and Binance accounts he identified separately. So why did only the Gate account get frozen? He asked that question directly, and so far nobody in officialdom has answered it.
Gate.io disputes the tracing. In a Nov. 15 statement, the exchange said its internal review — based on records supplied by police — points to a different transaction route entirely. Gate said it asked police for further evidence when the freeze request arrived in September 2025, and its anti-money-laundering team began requesting evidence at that point. A handover-related request followed in April 2026. Police told the exchange in September 2026 that the case remained under court review. No assets have been handed over.
The exchange acknowledged the court order and said it is working with local counsel to help the affected investor begin a formal defense. But there's a limit to what Gate can do. Its local lawyers advised that the exchange cannot challenge the order on the investor's behalf — only the investor can contest it through the Indian court process.
What does this change for exchange users?
Plenty. The case shows how unresolved chain-tracing disputes can leave funds locked indefinitely, with no clear mechanism for account holders to access assets while legal proceedings grind on. A compliance freeze built on third-party evidence can persist for months — here, more than a year — even when that evidence is actively contested.
The dispute also exposes a labeling problem. Compliance tools struggle to attribute transactions across layer-2 networks like Merlin Chain, where unlabeled addresses invite misattribution. Cross-border crypto tracing gets harder still when bridge infrastructure sits in the middle, and Indian law enforcement is still building its playbook for exactly this scenario.
There's a second, quieter detail in the file. ZachXBT said the same investor separately lost 7 BTC through a private-key compromise on July 15, 2025. That incident was reported to local police, with blockchain security firm SlowMist engaged, and the funds flowed to Wasabi — the Bitcoin mixer.
Why India complicates things
For Indian traders, the stakes extend beyond the freeze itself. Exchanges operating in India must register with FIU-IND and comply with anti-money-laundering rules. Indian crypto gains are taxed at a flat 30% under Section 115BBH, and a 1% TDS applies on VDA transfers under Section 194S. Frozen funds can complicate those tax obligations in ways nobody has fully worked out. The case also raises an open question: how Indian courts balance victim restitution against the rights of account holders when the tracing evidence itself is disputed.
The backdrop is familiar. Complex on-chain attribution work has become routine in enforcement — earlier reporting by BitcoinWorld traced Bybit hack funds to a Lazarus-linked network using a $349,700 sting.
For now, the next development sits with the Indian courts. Gate said it is seeking authorization to share additional evidence with ZachXBT and the affected user, which could clarify the disputed tracing. The investor's formal defense through the court process is the milestone to watch.
via cryptonews.net (Source)
More from Marcus Bennett
Show full bio
Senior reporter covering money, funding and market shifts around crypto and web3 industry at Mempool Brief.
1,456 articles