0x799740fe7997…79974101
Judge Clears MIT Brothers in $25M MEV Case, Says Ethereum Has No Terms of Use
Judge Jessica Clarke acquitted Anton and James Peraire-Bueno over a $25 million MEV exploit, ruling Ethereum is a trustless environment with no terms of use.

Outputs
Judge Jessica Clarke acquitted the Peraire-Bueno brothers on Nov. 16 on wire fraud and money laundering charges tied to $25 million.
The alleged exploit extracted $25 million in 12 seconds in April 2023.
A jury deadlocked and Clarke declared a mistrial in November 2025.
Clarke wrote that Ethereum is 'a trustless, highly adversarial environment with no terms of use.'
This was the first U.S. criminal case over an MEV exploit.
A federal judge in Manhattan has acquitted two MIT-educated brothers of fraud charges tied to a $25 million Ethereum trading exploit, ruling that outsmarting bots on a public blockchain doesn't amount to wire fraud. U.S. District Judge Jessica Clarke granted Anton and James Peraire-Bueno a judgment of acquittal on Nov. 16, according to her opinion, throwing out the U.S. government's first criminal case over a so-called MEV exploit and directing the court clerk to close the file.
The brothers stood accused of making $25 million in 12 seconds. Prosecutors charged them with wire fraud, conspiracy to commit wire fraud and conspiracy to commit money laundering. Clarke's ruling comes a year after a jury deadlocked and she declared a mistrial in November 2025.
At the heart of the decision is Clarke's reading of Ethereum itself. "It is a trustless, highly adversarial environment with no terms of use," she wrote of the network in her opinion.
How did the alleged exploit work?
Pending Ethereum transactions sit in a public queue known as the mempool until a validator — the network participant chosen to add the next block — includes them. Trading bots watch that queue to capture maximal extractable value, or MEV: the profit available to whoever controls the sequence of transactions inside a block.
The most common bot play is the sandwich. A bot spots a large pending buy, buys the token just ahead of it, lets the victim's purchase push the price up, and sells straight into the spike.
Most validators don't assemble their own blocks. They buy finished ones from specialized builders through on-chain intermediaries called relays. A relay keeps a block's contents secret until the validator signs a promise to publish it, which stops the validator from peeking at a builder's trades and stealing them.
That's the mechanism the brothers allegedly targeted. According to the court's opinion, they set their trap in April 2023 with eight bait transactions designed to attract sandwich bots.
What broke the relay's safeguards?
When it was their own validator's turn to propose a block, a relay called Ultrasound offered it a block stuffed with the bots' sandwich trades. The validator signed the block's header — a summary of its contents — with two crucial fields set to zero, describing a block that could never be valid.
Ultrasound didn't check those fields. It handed over the block's contents anyway, exposing the bots' trades.
What does the ruling change?
The acquittal closes out the Justice Department's first attempt to prosecute an MEV manipulation as criminal fraud, and Clarke's language sets a marker for how courts may treat adversarial conduct on permissionless chains. Her framing — that Ethereum's design assumes adversarial participants and carries no terms of use — suggests prosecutors will need a different theory, such as unauthorized access to computer systems, to bring similar cases in the future. For now, the Peraire-Bueno case stands as the reference point, and any follow-on prosecution will have to route around it.
via cryptonews.net (Source)
More from Daniel Okafor
Show full bio
Correspondent covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in crypto and web3 industry at Mempool Brief.
1,514 articles