0x1423c8311423…1423c834

ConfirmedTokenization & RWA560 vB87 sat/vB3 min decode

Cardano DReps Reject $3.3 Million Copper Reserve Proposal From Toto Finance

Cardano DReps holding 2.86 billion ADA rejected Toto Finance's plan to spend 22 million ADA on a copper reserve, citing double price exposure and a fee-heavy structure.

Cardano Holders Put Billions of ADA Coins to Block $5 Million Copper Reserve
WitnessCardano Holders Put Billions of ADA Coins to Block $5 Million Copper Reserveechosystem / pixabay

Outputs

  1. DReps holding 2.86 billion ADA rejected the 22 million ADA copper reserve proposal on Nov. 15.

  2. Toto Finance, led by Monty Metzger, filed the proposal on Oct. 15; it planned to buy copper with 14.72 million ADA stored near New Orleans.

  3. At $0.152 per ADA, the requested 22 million ADA was worth about $3.3 million on Monday.

  4. The Cardano Foundation voted no, citing sole recipient control and fees of up to 3.4 million ADA.

  5. Three Constitutional Committee members voted no; four did not vote.

Cardano's decentralized representatives have voted down a plan to spend 22 million ADA from the project's treasury on a physical copper stockpile. The vote closed on Nov. 15, and governance data shows the rejection was not close. DReps holding 2.86 billion ADA voted no. Only 20.02 million ADA backed the idea.

At Monday's price of $0.152, the requested 22 million ADA works out to roughly $3.3 million. The proposal came from Toto Finance, a company led by Monty Metzger, and was filed on Oct. 15.

The plan itself was concrete. Toto Finance intended to use 14.72 million ADA to buy copper and store the metal in a warehouse near New Orleans. It would then issue one CuTT token per pound of copper. The stockpile would be sold after 18 to 24 months.

The rest of the treasury allocation, under the structure critics described, would have flowed to Toto Finance as fees.

Why did DReps say no?

DRep John MacPherson voted against and explained his reasoning on X. He wrote that he is not opposed to real-world assets on Cardano. His problem was the structure. He said the proposal asks the treasury "to take on both the copper price and the ada price," while Toto Finance would collect "up to about 3.4M ada in fees."

He was not entirely harsh on the pitch. MacPherson also noted the proposal is "more honest about its risks than most."

The Cardano Foundation, which participates in governance as a DRep itself, announced its no vote in October. Its statement was blunt.

"We recognize the opportunity in real-world asset tokenization; however, this proposal places 22,000,000 ada under the recipient's sole control to fund a fee-heavy concentrated commodity position whose safeguards are not yet in place," the foundation wrote.

Three members of the Constitutional Committee voted no. The other four did not vote at all.

Crypto commentator Ingeniero Cripto echoed MacPherson's concerns in the replies. He called the "double exposure" to copper and ADA prices the proposal's core defect. The logic is straightforward: the Cardano treasury already holds ADA. Buying copper with ADA means the treasury's purchasing outcome depends on two moving prices at once.

His broader framing drew a clean line. Real-world assets on Cardano make sense, he argued, but "funding the asset itself is a different question than funding the rails."

What does this change for treasury governance?

For one thing, it shows the post-Chang governance machine can kill a well-documented proposal by an identifiable company, not just rubber-stamp technical housekeeping. DReps, the Foundation and the Constitutional Committee all engaged on substance. Three of the seven committee members abstaining is a wrinkle worth watching, but the outcome was never in doubt.

It also sets an early precedent on scope. Treasury funds building infrastructure, not taking concentrated commodity positions. A tokenized copper warehouse may yet find a home on Cardano. It will just need private capital behind it, working safeguards, and a fee structure that survives DRep scrutiny.

Toto Finance could resubmit a revised proposal, and the 18-to-24-month copper thesis it sketched has effectively expired with this vote. Any future attempt will have to answer the same question that sank this one: who carries the risk, and who collects the fees.

via cryptonews.net (Source)

More from Marcus Bennett

Marcus Bennett

Show full bio

Senior reporter covering money, funding and market shifts around crypto and web3 industry at Mempool Brief.

1,456 articles