0x1e883e851e88…1e883e88

ConfirmedTokenization & RWA466 vB89 sat/vB2 min decode

Cardano Voters Reject $5M Copper Reserve Plan by Over 140 to 1

Cardano DReps voted down Toto Finance's 22 million ADA copper reserve plan by more than 140 to 1, preserving 42.6 million ADA of treasury withdrawal capacity through July 2027.

Cardano Voters Reject $5M Copper Plan by More Than 140 to 1
WitnessCardano Voters Reject $5M Copper Plan by More Than 140 to 1Tho-Ge / pixabay

Outputs

  1. Cardano DReps rejected Toto Finance's 22 million ADA request on November 15, 2026, by 2.86 billion ADA to 20.02 million ADA.

  2. Toto could have collected up to 3.36 million ADA (about 15%) in fees, despite founder Monty Metzger saying "Toto takes no profit from this proposal."

  3. Copper would have needed to rise about 49% for the treasury to break even if ADA's dollar price stayed flat.

  4. The Constitutional Committee voted 3 no and 4 abstentions on the proposal.

  5. Only 42.6 million ADA of the 500 million ADA withdrawal cap remains as of October 16, 2026, with the cap running through July 2027.

Cardano's delegated representatives rejected Toto Finance's request for 22 million ADA, killing a roughly $5 million plan to buy warehouse copper and tokenize it. Voting closed on November 15, 2026, with 2.86 billion ADA in voting power cast against the proposal and 20.02 million ADA in favor — an opposition margin of more than 140 to 1.

Treasury withdrawals require yes votes from 67% of active voting stake. Toto's request received less than 1% of the stake that voted for or against it. Another 131 million ADA registered no confidence.

What did the Constitutional Committee decide?

The Constitutional Committee, which reviews spending requests against Cardano's constitution separately from the funding vote, also withheld support. Three members voted no, while four did not vote.

The Cardano Foundation had opposed the plan in October. Its concerns included giving the recipient sole control of 22 million ADA for a concentrated commodity position, along with substantial fees and safeguards that were not yet in place.

Why did ADA holders object?

DRep John MacPherson argued that the treasury would face exposure to both copper prices and ADA prices simultaneously. He supports real-world assets on Cardano in principle, but called the proposal, in his words, "more honest about its risks than most," as U.Today reported.

The economics compounded the concern. Copper would have needed to rise about 49% for the treasury to recover its ADA outlay if ADA's dollar price stayed flat, according to CoinDesk's account of its October analysis.

What fees were attached to the proposal?

Toto could have collected up to approximately 3.36 million ADA — roughly 15% of the request — in technology, management and execution fees, plus margins on storage and insurance invoices. Founder Monty Metzger nevertheless said: "Toto takes no profit from this proposal."

Led by Metzger, Toto Finance submitted the request on October 15, 2026. The plan allocated 14.72 million ADA to buy COMEX-grade copper stored in a warehouse near New Orleans, and proposed issuing a CuTT token backed by the physical metal — one CuTT per pound of copper. The proposed holding period ran 18 to 24 months, with proceeds due back to the treasury by month 36.

What happens to the treasury cap now?

Cardano holders set a 500 million ADA withdrawal cap, which runs through approximately July 2027. As of October 16, 2026, 457.4 million ADA was already committed, leaving 42.6 million ADA of capacity. Toto's request would have consumed about 52% of that remainder, so the rejection preserves the balance for other applicants.

Toto could submit another funding proposal, potentially revising its fees, asset controls or safeguards in response to voters' objections. Any revised request must still clear the 67% approval threshold within the remaining cap window before July 2027.

via bitcoinfoundation.org (Source)

More from Tom Whitfield

Tom Whitfield

Show full bio

News editor covering technology and product news in crypto and web3 industry at Mempool Brief.

1,374 articles