0x1e4433871e44…1e44338a

ConfirmedRegulation & Policy593 vB53 sat/vB3 min decode

Judge clears Peraire-Bueno brothers in alleged $25 million MEV case

A federal judge acquitted Anton and James Peraire-Bueno of wire fraud and related charges in an alleged $25 million Ethereum MEV-Boost exploit, while leaving other legal theories open.

US judge clears brothers in $25M Ethereum MEV case after mistrial
WitnessUS judge clears brothers in $25M Ethereum MEV case after mistrialPriismaDesign / pixabay

Outputs

  1. Judge Jessica Clarke acquitted Anton and James Peraire-Bueno on Monday on wire fraud and related charges.

  2. Prosecutors alleged the brothers exploited MEV-Boost software on Ethereum in April 2023.

  3. The alleged scheme generated $25 million in about 12 seconds.

  4. The first trial ended in a mistrial in November 2025.

  5. Clarke cited a 2025 Mango Markets decision involving Avraham Eisenberg.

A U.S. federal judge on Monday acquitted MIT-educated brothers Anton and James Peraire-Bueno of wire fraud and related charges in a case built around an alleged $25 million Ethereum trading-bot exploit. Prosecutors said the scheme took about 12 seconds.

Judge Jessica Clarke said prosecutors failed to prove that the brothers made material misrepresentations during the alleged April 2023 exploit. She concluded that the transactions did not amount to false promises or constitute criminal fraud, according to the ruling.

What did prosecutors allege?

Prosecutors alleged that the brothers exploited a flaw in maximal extractable value, or MEV-Boost, software on Ethereum in April 2023. Their theory was that the flaw let them lure sandwich-trading bots into transactions and then disrupt those trades, generating $25 million in about 12 seconds.

The ruling did not validate prosecutors’ criminal-fraud theory. It establishes that prosecutors failed to prove material misrepresentations on these charges, not that the alleged bot disruption never occurred. Practically, the prosecution lost on fraud, not necessarily on the underlying conduct.

What did the ruling decide?\n

Clarke expressly separated criminal fraud from broader legal and ethical judgments. The judge said the case did not decide whether the brothers’ conduct was ethical or potentially violated other laws, so the verdict cannot be read as comprehensive exoneration.

The ruling therefore rejects the prosecution’s wire-fraud theory on this record while leaving other legal theories open. In short, the court rejected the criminal-fraud case, not every possible legal claim.

Why was there a second trial?

The brothers’ first trial ended in a mistrial in November 2025 because jurors failed to reach a verdict. Monday’s ruling then resolved the charges. The decisive point was the failure to prove material misrepresentations, rather than a ruling on the ethics of the strategy.

The procedural history matters because no jury verdict had fixed the outcome before Clarke ruled. In short, the mistrial left the case without a verdict until the court delivered the acquittal.

What did Coin Center argue?

Coin Center Executive Director Peter Van Valkenburgh called the acquittal “excellent news.” He said prosecutors’ honest validator theory risked allowing the government to impose its own standards of conduct on Ethereum validators through wire-fraud laws.

“Anyone participating in an open network would have to wonder whether prosecutors might later declare their behavior ‘dishonest’ and haul them into court,” Valkenburgh said. That was Coin Center’s policy argument, not the judge’s finding, and the distinction leaves the broader enforcement concern unresolved.

How did the Mango Markets case figure in?

Clarke also cited a 2025 decision involving Mango Markets trader Avraham Eisenberg. In that case, a judge found insufficient evidence of false representations, and Clarke cited the decision on the misrepresentation issue in the Peraire-Bueno prosecution.

The precedent supports only a narrow point: prosecutors need evidence of false representations to establish the relevant criminal-fraud theory. It does not establish that the brothers’ conduct was ethical or lawful under every other law. The comparison supports the evidentiary reasoning, not a blanket declaration that the conduct was lawful.

Where does enforcement stand?

MEV trading also returns to court in a separate Pump.fun class-action lawsuit. Nothing in that related case changes the brothers’ federal acquittal.

For Ethereum validators and other open-network participants, the practical issue is whether prosecutors can apply other laws to conduct for which this prosecution failed to prove criminal fraud. The next enforcement test will be any future attempt to frame comparable MEV conduct under those other legal theories.

via fingfx.thomsonreuters.com (Original)

More from Elena Vasquez

Elena Vasquez

Show full bio

Staff writer covering regulation, policy and their impact on crypto and web3 industry at Mempool Brief.

1,525 articles