0x3357f8383357…3357f83b
MIT Brothers Acquitted in $25 Million Ethereum MEV Case
A federal judge acquitted the Peraire-Bueno brothers in the first U.S. MEV prosecution, rejecting fraud and money-laundering charges in an alleged $25 million Ethereum exploit.

Outputs
U.S. District Judge Jessica Clarke acquitted Anton and James Peraire-Bueno on Monday, Nov. 16.
The ruling covered three charges: wire fraud, conspiracy to commit wire fraud and conspiracy to commit money laundering.
Prosecutors alleged that eight bait transactions and a relay-software flaw caused about $25 million in losses from 2023 Ethereum transaction ordering.
Three findings supported the acquittal: the bait transactions were not promises, the relay did not check a spoofed field and the field did not affect recipient actions.
A jury deadlocked in 2025, producing a mistrial before the later acquittal.
By Nathan Brooks
U.S. District Judge Jessica Clarke acquitted Anton Peraire-Bueno and James Peraire-Bueno on Monday, Nov. 16, according to her ruling in a federal case alleging a $25 million exploit of Ethereum transaction ordering. Clarke found the MIT brothers not guilty of:
- Wire fraud.
- Conspiracy to commit wire fraud.
- Conspiracy to commit money laundering.
The acquittal follows a 2025 jury deadlock that produced a mistrial. It closes the first U.S. criminal prosecution targeting maximum extractable value, or MEV, trading. In this case, MEV arose from Ethereum transaction ordering, where placement mattered to the bots’ losses.
What did prosecutors allege?
Prosecutors accused the brothers of using eight bait transactions to draw sandwich-trading bots into a scheme built around Ethereum transaction ordering. They alleged that the brothers exploited a flaw in relay software to reorder transactions and cause about $25 million in losses.
Prosecutors made the eight transactions the alleged entry point for a strategy they said generated roughly $25 million in losses. The case therefore turned on the legal character of the bait transactions and the relay’s handling of transaction data, not only on the size of the claimed loss.
What did the court find?
Clarke ruled that the bait transactions did not amount to promises, a key element in the wire fraud case. Her ruling also found that the relay did not check a spoofed field and that the field did not affect the recipient’s actions.
Those findings address both sides of the prosecution’s theory: whether the bait transactions carried a promise, and whether the spoofed field had any operational effect. The court did not treat the existence of approximately $25 million in alleged losses as a substitute for proof of the charged offenses.
What does the acquittal change for practitioners?
For automated traders and relay operators, the decision draws a boundary around the prosecution’s theory rather than around Ethereum transaction ordering itself. A transaction sequence that rearranges trades does not, on this record, establish the promise that prosecutors needed for wire fraud.
For relay developers, the verdict highlights verification of client-supplied fields as an evidentiary issue. For bot operators, it shows that a strategy’s scale and an alleged $25 million loss do not answer the separate question of what each party promised and what the software actually did.
Still, the ruling is not a general declaration that MEV strategies are lawful. It resolves this prosecution on the elements the court examined, leaving other conduct to be assessed under charges and facts not presented in this case.
What happens after the 2025 mistrial?
After the jury deadlocked in 2025, the court resolved the case rather than leaving the mistrial as the final outcome. The acquittal now leaves the eight-transaction theory without a criminal verdict and ends the federal case against the brothers.
The next checkpoint is how Ethereum trading infrastructure responds to the ruling. The practical question for operators and counterparties is whether transaction-ordering systems can document what they promise, which fields they verify and how those choices affect recipients.
The litigation phase has ended; any resulting market-structure change will begin with how relay developers and bot operators document and verify transaction-ordering assumptions.
via tokenpost.com (Source)
More from Nathan Brooks
Show full bio
Market editor covering money, funding and market shifts around crypto and web3 industry at Mempool Brief.
1,512 articles