0x474cd1a8474c…474cd1a5

ConfirmedRegulation & Policy801 vB70 sat/vB4 min decode

Supreme Court Declines Custodia Bank's Master Account Appeal

The Supreme Court declined Custodia Bank's appeal, leaving a 2–1 Tenth Circuit ruling that Fed Reserve Banks may deny master accounts to legally eligible applicants.

Supreme Court Declines Custodia Bank’s Fed Master Account Appeal
WitnessSupreme Court Declines Custodia Bank’s Fed Master Account AppealChiemSeherin / pixabay

Outputs

  1. Supreme Court denied certiorari in Custodia Bank v. Federal Reserve, case No. 26-62, on November 16, 2026

  2. Tenth Circuit's October 31, 2025 ruling held Reserve Banks may deny master accounts to legally eligible nonmember banks, 2–1

  3. Kansas City Fed rejected Custodia's master account application on January 27, 2023, after an October 2020 filing

  4. Judge Tymkovich dissented: "shall means shall"; denial is "akin to a death sentence"

  5. Full Tenth Circuit denied rehearing March 13, 2026; Judges Hartz, Tymkovich and Eid voted to grant it

By Elena Vasquez

The U.S. Supreme Court on November 16, 2026 declined to hear Custodia Bank's appeal in case No. 26-62, leaving intact a 2–1 Tenth Circuit ruling that regional Federal Reserve Banks may deny master accounts even to legally eligible applicants. The one-line order ends the Wyoming bank's petition-driven bid to compel direct access to the Federal Reserve's payment system.

Custodia Bank, Inc. v. Federal Reserve Board of Governors appeared under "certiorari denied" on the Monday order list. The procedural outcome leaves the lower-court judgment undisturbed; the controlling reasoning remains the Tenth Circuit's interpretation of federal banking law, not a Supreme Court merits opinion. That distinction matters. The surviving precedent binds within the Tenth Circuit while leaving the national question unanswered.

What decision survives?

The Tenth Circuit's October 31, 2025 ruling upheld the Kansas City Fed's discretion to reject Custodia's application. The majority held that meeting the legal requirements to apply does not create an enforceable right to receive an account.

Custodia had asked the Court to review whether regional Reserve Bank presidents could deny master accounts to legally eligible nonmember banks. Kannon Shanmugam filed the July 2026 petition. Both the Board of Governors and the Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City opposed review.

A six-year path from application to denial

Custodia applied to the Kansas City Fed for a master account in October 2020. The Reserve Bank confirmed its legal eligibility in January 2021 and reportedly saw "no showstoppers." The application then sat pending. Custodia submitted a separate membership application to the Board of Governors in August 2021.

In June 2022, Custodia sued over the delay. In August 2022, while the requests were pending, the Board published master-account review guidelines that placed institutions without federal deposit insurance or federal supervision into Tier 3 — the strictest review category. Custodia fell into it.

Both applications were rejected on January 27, 2023. The Kansas City Fed called Custodia's model "unprecedented" and "narrowly focused on crypto-asset activities," concluding the risks were highly likely to be inconsistent with safe and sound banking practices. The Board said membership approval would be inconsistent with the financial, managerial and corporate powers factors. These were the Fed's assessments; Custodia has continued to argue for the merits of its model, though no merits ruling has ever endorsed it.

Judge Scott W. Skavdahl ruled against Custodia on March 29, 2024, holding that Reserve Banks have discretion over master accounts, dismissing the Administrative Procedure Act claim for lack of final agency action, and granting the Kansas City Fed summary judgment. The Tenth Circuit affirmed; the full court denied rehearing on March 13, 2026, over the votes of Judges Hartz, Tymkovich and Eid.

The ruling turns on "may" and "shall"

Judge David Ebel, joined by Judge Veronica Rossman, read Section 342 of the Federal Reserve Act — which says a Reserve Bank "may receive" deposits — as permission, not obligation. Custodia's counterargument relied on the Monetary Control Act of 1980, which says Federal Reserve services "shall be available" to nonmember banks; the majority treated that as a pricing rule rather than an account entitlement.

Judge Timothy Tymkovich dissented. "We are bound by the ordinary language of the statute and, in my view, shall means shall," he wrote. He also called master-account denial "akin to a death sentence" in his dissent from the rehearing denial — his assessment of exclusion from those services. The majority's reading prevailed nonetheless.

What are the operational consequences?

A master account would give Custodia direct access to Fedwire and other Federal Reserve payment services. Without one, a state-chartered bank must route dollars through a correspondent institution, an intermediary dependency Custodia argued limited the competitiveness of digital-asset banks.

Custodia is a Wyoming special purpose depository institution led by chief executive Caitlin Long. Its charter prohibits lending and requires dollar deposits to be fully reserved in liquid assets — safeguards Custodia presented as run protection. The Kansas City Fed instead weighed the risks of a crypto-concentrated business model. Under the surviving interpretation, the Reserve Bank could refuse access even after acknowledging legal eligibility.

For other novel charter holders, the takeaway is plain: a charter establishes eligibility to apply, not entitlement to an account. The Defiant reports the Fed is developing a narrower payment-account model, an initiative that may eventually reshape this framework; the current master-account rules remain in force.

The petition ran from a November 13, 2026 conference to the November 16 order list, closing a dispute that began with a 2020 application. Regional Reserve Banks retain discretion, and rejected applicants within the Tenth Circuit now face limited judicial recourse — unless Congress amends the statute or the Fed's pending payment-account work changes the access question administratively.

via bitcoinfoundation.org (Source)

More from Elena Vasquez

Elena Vasquez

Show full bio

Staff writer covering regulation, policy and their impact on crypto and web3 industry at Mempool Brief.

1,525 articles