0x0ab2ec8c0ab2…0ab2ec89

ConfirmedRegulation & Policy678 vB148 sat/vB3 min decode

Supreme Court declines Custodia’s Fed master-account appeal

The Supreme Court declined Custodia’s challenge to a Federal Reserve denial of direct payment access, leaving a 2-1 appellate ruling and case-by-case approvals for crypto banks intact.

Supreme Court rejects Custodia Bank’s bid for Fed payment access
WitnessSupreme Court rejects Custodia Bank’s bid for Fed payment access3844328 / pixabay

Outputs

  1. The Supreme Court declined review without an explanation, leaving the 10th Circuit ruling intact.

  2. The 10th Circuit upheld the Federal Reserve decision 2-1 on October 31, 2025.

  3. Custodia applied in October 2020; the Kansas City Fed rejected the application in January 2023.

  4. A Wyoming district court sided with the Fed in March 2024.

  5. The Kansas City Fed granted Kraken Financial a limited-purpose master account in March 2025.

The U.S. Supreme Court has declined to review a 2-1 ruling that upheld the Federal Reserve’s denial of Custodia Bank’s master-account application, leaving the central bank’s discretion intact.

Chartered in Wyoming as a special purpose depository institution, or SPDI, Custodia applied for a master account in October 2020. The charter type was designed for banks focused on digital assets. The Kansas City Fed considered the application for years before formally rejecting it in January 2023.

The Fed cited two risks: Custodia’s heavy concentration in crypto activity and its limited experience with traditional risk management.

Custodia sued. A Wyoming district court sided with the Fed in March 2024, and on October 31, 2025, the 10th Circuit Court of Appeals upheld that result in a 2-1 split.

The appeal and dissent

The majority read the plain language of the governing statutes to give the Fed discretion, not an obligation, to provide services. Judge Timothy Tymkovich disagreed. In his dissent, he argued that the statutes required Fed services to be “available” to eligible institutions, full stop, and likened denial of a master account to a “death sentence” for a bank.

The case turned on the Federal Reserve Act and the Monetary Control Act of 1980. The legal question was whether eligible banks had a right to Fed services or only qualified for a discretionary decision. Custodia argued eligibility created an entitlement. The Fed argued it did not. Every court that considered the issue sided with the Fed.

The majority’s reading separates regulatory qualification from guaranteed service. An institution can meet the statutory threshold and still face a discretionary decision on access. Tymkovich read “available” as a duty, which would have converted eligibility into an enforceable entitlement rather than a place in line.

The Supreme Court’s decision not to take the case leaves that interpretation in place. Certiorari denials carry no explanation, so the court did not state why it declined review. The practical result is what Custodia wanted to avoid: its application remains denied, while the 10th Circuit precedent stands without a contrary Supreme Court ruling.

Kraken shows discretion in practice

In March 2025, the same Kansas City Fed granted Kraken Financial, another crypto-focused institution, a limited-purpose master account. The contrast means the Fed has not adopted a categorical bar against digital asset banks. It has instead made case-by-case calls, assessing each applicant’s risk profile and approving some applications while rejecting others.

Supporters of the Fed’s position view that discretion as proper. Critics see an inconsistent record, in which similar businesses receive materially different answers with little clarity about why.

For applicants, the contrast is operational. Access remains possible for a crypto-focused institution, but the Fed still evaluates each applicant’s risk profile. Similar business models do not guarantee similar outcomes, and the public record provides limited clarity on why one institution receives a limited-purpose account while another is denied.

What does this change for crypto-focused banks?

The ruling raises the cost of trying to obtain a master account through litigation. Custodia spent years and considerable legal effort pursuing direct access and finishes without a favorable court outcome.

Any digital asset bank that now challenges a denial faces a steeper climb. The 10th Circuit’s reading of the statutes stands, and the Supreme Court has shown no appetite to revisit it. Future applicants must persuade the Kansas City Fed directly rather than expect a court to compel access.

Congress is the next likely pressure point. If lawmakers want eligibility to guarantee Fed services, they must write that duty explicitly into law; the courts have interpreted the existing statutes as leaving the decision with the Fed. The dispute concerns the default rule for eligible institutions, not merely the facts of Custodia’s application.

Absent an explicit congressional mandate, the Fed’s case-by-case control over master-account access is likely to remain the market structure for crypto-focused banks, leaving future applicants to win discretionary approval rather than a judicially enforceable entitlement.

via cryptonews.net (Source)

More from Nathan Brooks

Nathan Brooks

Show full bio

Market editor covering money, funding and market shifts around crypto and web3 industry at Mempool Brief.

1,512 articles