0x5fac48c35fac…5fac48c6
Supreme Court Ends Custodia Bank's Six-Year Master Account Fight
The Supreme Court denied Custodia Bank's cert petition on November 16, 2026, leaving intact the Tenth Circuit ruling that Reserve Banks may reject master account applications from eligible crypto banks.

Outputs
The Supreme Court denied Custodia Bank's cert petition on November 16, 2026, without opinion.
The Tenth Circuit's October 31, 2025 ruling held Reserve Banks may reject master account applications from eligible nonmember institutions.
The Kansas City Fed denied Custodia's master account and the Board denied its membership application on the same day in January 2023.
Kraken Financial, under the same Wyoming SPDI charter, announced a master account in March 2026 after five-plus years of engagement.
Custodia waited just over six years from its October 2020 application for a final answer.
The U.S. Supreme Court denied Custodia Bank's petition for certiorari on November 16, 2026, ending a six-year effort to force the Federal Reserve to grant the Wyoming-chartered crypto bank a master account. The denial, issued without opinion, leaves the Tenth Circuit's October 31, 2025 ruling in place: Reserve Banks may reject master account applications from statutorily eligible institutions.
The case, Custodia Bank v. Federal Reserve Board of Governors, turned on one clause. Section 248a(c)(2) of the Monetary Control Act requires that Federal Reserve services listed on the fee schedule "shall be available to nonmember depository institutions." Custodia argued that access to a master account — the account through which Fedwire settlement is reached — followed automatically from that eligibility.
What did the Tenth Circuit actually hold?
The appellate court separated pricing from access. Section 248a, it held, sets fee principles for the Board of Governors. Account authority comes from Section 342 of the Federal Reserve Act, which grants Reserve Banks discretionary power to receive deposits. "The plain language of the three statutory provisions grants Reserve Banks the discretion to reject master account applications from eligible entities," the majority wrote.
The court's most quoted line will recur in briefs for years. Reading Custodia's interpretation into the statute would be "to find an elephant in a mousehole," the panel concluded, invoking the principle that Congress "does not hide elephants in mouseholes."
The strongest textual evidence against Custodia came from a transparency measure. The Toomey Amendment, enacted in 2022 within the National Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2023 and codified at Section 11C of the Federal Reserve Act, requires the Board to publish a searchable database of every master account holder and applicant, marking each request approved, rejected, pending or withdrawn. The court drew a direct inference: "Congress envisioned that Reserve Banks would reject some master account applications from eligible entities."
How did the denial unfold?
The Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City confirmed in January 2021 that Custodia was legally eligible and reported "no showstoppers." The bank applied for Federal Reserve membership in August 2021 to secure federal supervision. On a single day in January 2023, the Reserve Bank denied the master account and the Board denied membership.
Applying the Board's 2022 Guidelines, the Kansas City Fed found Custodia's "unprecedented" business model, "narrowly focused on crypto-asset activities," carried risks "highly likely [to be] inconsistent with safe and sound banking practices" without federal oversight or stronger controls. Custodia sued in the District of Wyoming in June 2022, won nothing at summary judgment in 2024, and lost at the Tenth Circuit with one judge dissenting. The petition took 381 days from the appellate ruling to dispose of.
Custodia's Wyoming special purpose depository institution charter permits dollar deposits and digital asset custody but prohibits lending and requires full liquid-asset backing. That structure reduced depositor risk, in the Reserve Bank's assessment, but left the consolidated supervision question unanswered.
Why did Kraken succeed where Custodia failed?
The same state charter produced the opposite outcome. Kraken Financial, operating under the identical Wyoming SPDI framework, announced in March 2026 that it had received a master account — the first for a digital asset bank in the United States, following more than five years of regulatory engagement. Kraken said the account lets it settle over Fedwire without correspondent intermediaries.
The Tenth Circuit's discretionary framework makes the contrast legally unremarkable. Case-by-case evaluation under the 2022 Guidelines permits different outcomes for similarly chartered institutions, based on risk profile, supervision and controls that the Reserve Bank need not reduce to a formula.
What does the dissent signal for future cases?
Judge Tymkovich's dissent framed the dispute as constitutional. "By claiming unreviewable discretion over access to the nation's financial system, the Fed has gone too far," he wrote, arguing the majority's reading "allows unappointed bank officials to exercise significant yet unreviewable executive authority." His alternative: the Monetary Control Act "mandated access for all nonmember depository institutions."
Without direct access, Tymkovich noted, banks reach Fed services only "through a correspondent banking relationship or expensive third-party service providers" — a cost layer that matters acutely for Custodia, which earns transaction fees on a business it cannot lend against. The bank retains its charter and custody operations under Wyoming supervision; what it lost is the legal argument that federal law compels a Fed connection.
What remains open?
Applicants retain two routes: apply directly and accept Reserve Bank discretion, or pursue federal charters, as Rain did with its OCC national trust bank filing for stablecoin custody. Neither guarantees rail access, and the Board's proposed rules under the GENIUS Act framework remain in progress. Senator Cynthia Lummis filed an amicus brief supporting the petition; former Senator Pat Toomey, whose amendment anchored the majority's reasoning, filed at the appellate merits stage.
The Tenth Circuit's holding binds only within its circuit, so a future appellate split remains possible. Custodia's docket shows no filing after November 16, and the bank has not stated whether it will reapply, seek a different charter, or operate through correspondents. Until Congress converts eligibility into entitlement — the outcome the court said current statutes do not provide — master account access stays a discretionary decision made at the Reserve Banks.
via cryptonews.net (Source)
More from Tom Whitfield
Show full bio
News editor covering technology and product news in crypto and web3 industry at Mempool Brief.
1,374 articles