0x407a5457407a…407a545a

ConfirmedRegulation & Policy736 vB171 sat/vB4 min decode

Manhattan Judge Acquits MIT Brothers in $25M Ethereum MEV Case

Judge Jessica Clarke acquitted the Peraire-Bueno brothers over a $25M MEV exploit, finding no material misrepresentation in a trustless environment with no terms of use.

Judge Acquits MIT Brothers in $25M Ethereum MEV Case, Ending Prosecution
WitnessJudge Acquits MIT Brothers in $25M Ethereum MEV Case, Ending ProsecutionDaniel_B_photos / pixabay

Outputs

  1. Manhattan judge Jessica Clarke acquitted Anton and James Peraire-Bueno of all charges over a $25 million exploit.

  2. The April 2023 attack drained sandwich bots of $25 million in roughly 12 seconds.

  3. The ruling followed a mistrial in November 2025 after a deadlocked jury.

  4. Clarke found prosecutors failed to show a material misrepresentation, required for wire fraud.

  5. Ethereum was described as a trustless environment with no terms of use, defeating the fraud theory.

A Manhattan federal judge has acquitted Anton and James Peraire-Bueno of all charges tied to a 2023 exploit that drained $25 million from Ethereum trading bots, ending the criminal case without a retrial. U.S. District Judge Jessica Clarke granted the brothers' motion for a judgment of acquittal on Monday, clearing them of wire fraud, conspiracy to commit wire fraud, and conspiracy to commit money laundering. The ruling closes a prosecution the government itself called a "first of its kind" in its indictment.

The decision lands roughly a year after the brothers' first trial collapsed. Clarke declared a mistrial in November 2025 after the jury deadlocked, and Monday's acquittal means the case ends there — no second trial, no conviction on any count.

Why did the judge throw out the case?

The core of the ruling is narrow and technical. To convict on wire fraud, prosecutors had to prove the brothers made a material misrepresentation. Clarke found that none of the government's theories cleared that bar.

"The question before the Court is not whether the Peraire-Buenos' conduct was right or moral, or even whether it violated uncharged crimes," Clarke wrote. Ethereum, she noted, is a "trustless, highly adversarial environment with no terms of use." That framing matters. If a network has no terms of use, the judge reasoned, exploiting its mechanics does not automatically amount to deceiving a counterparty in the way fraud law requires.

The brothers' scheme, Clarke acknowledged, "may have frustrated the spirit" of MEV-Boost — the software that lets Ethereum validators outsource transaction ordering to specialized block builders. Frustrating a system's spirit is not the legal test. The prosecution, she added in a footnote, "raises serious due process concerns," though she declined to rule on that question. The caveat is notable: she flagged a constitutional problem in how the case was built, but left it unresolved.

The money laundering count fell with the fraud counts. Because it relied on the proceeds of the alleged wire fraud, and the fraud theory failed, the laundering charge could not stand on its own.

The takeaway in plain words: the judge did not endorse the conduct, she found the fraud statute never fit it.

How did the $25 million exploit work?

The case stemmed from an April 2023 attack on so-called sandwich bots. These are automated traders that profit from maximal extractable value, or MEV, by placing their own trades on either side of other users' transactions — a practice that extracts value from ordinary users' activity on Ethereum.

According to the ruling, the brothers placed bait transactions designed to lure specific bots. They then exploited a bug in a relay's code that let them see the bots' bundled trades before committing to a block. In the final step, they swapped the bait transactions for trades that sold the tokens instead. The bots were left with roughly $25 million in losses, accumulated in about 12 seconds — a sum comparable to what a median U.S. household earns in roughly four centuries, taken in less time than a human breath.

Authorities arrested the pair in May 2024. Prosecutors said the brothers, both MIT-educated, spent months planning the attack and took deliberate steps to hide the proceeds. At trial last year, an insider testified about the alleged planning, and the defense had earlier sought to block evidence of the brothers' Google searches. The jury still could not reach a verdict.

The takeaway: the factual account of the exploit was never seriously disputed — the legal theory built on top of it was what failed.

What does the acquittal change?

The case was closely watched across the crypto industry precisely because it tested whether fraud statutes can reach on-chain exploitation. Clarke's ruling supplies an answer, at least in this district: where a protocol operates as an adversarial environment without terms of use, prosecutors cannot bootstrap an ordering exploit into wire fraud without a concrete misrepresentation.

That leaves a gap. Conduct the judge described as possibly immoral, and possibly criminal under uncharged theories, now sits outside this particular enforcement framework. The Justice Department could pursue different charges in future MEV cases — computer fraud statutes among them — but nothing in Monday's ruling signals which direction it will take.

Whether prosecutors adapt their charging strategy to on-chain exploits, or Congress moves to define the conduct, is now the open question for this enforcement window.

via google.com (Original)

More from Elena Vasquez

Elena Vasquez

Show full bio

Staff writer covering regulation, policy and their impact on crypto and web3 industry at Mempool Brief.

1,525 articles