bde83e29-0

ConfirmedRegulation & Policy630 words3 min decode

Supreme Court Refuses Custodia Bank's Bid for Fed Master Account

The Supreme Court denied certiorari in Custodia Bank's case against the Federal Reserve, ending a six-year fight and leaving the Fed's discretionary power over master account approvals intact.

Supreme Court rejects Custodia Bank’s bid for Fed master account
WitnessSupreme Court rejects Custodia Bank’s bid for Fed master accountmarkusspiske / pixabay

Outputs

  1. Supreme Court denied certiorari in Custodia Bank v. Federal Reserve Board on Monday, ending the six-year case.

  2. Kansas City Fed denied Custodia's 2020 master account application in January 2023 over crypto business-model concerns.

  3. A March appeals court ruling, now final, holds the Fed has discretion to approve or deny master accounts.

  4. Kraken's banking division became the first crypto company to obtain a Fed master account in March.

  5. The Fed's proposed 'skinny master account' would bar interest on balances and discount window access.

The U.S. Supreme Court on Monday denied Custodia Bank's petition for a writ of certiorari, closing the Wyoming-chartered firm's six-year effort to force the Federal Reserve to grant it a master account. The denial, published in the court's weekly order list, leaves intact a lower-court ruling that the Fed has discretion to approve or deny master accounts for eligible institutions.

Custodia, a crypto-focused bank founded by Wall Street veteran Caitlin Long, applied for a master account with the Kansas City Fed in 2020. A master account gives an institution direct access to the Fed's payment systems — the most direct access to the U.S. money supply available to a financial firm. Institutions without one typically must route services through partner banks that hold the account for them, a structural dependency that raises cost and adds an intermediary to every settlement.

The Kansas City Fed denied the application in January 2023, citing concerns about Custodia's crypto-related business model. Custodia had already sued the Kansas City Fed in June 2022, first over a 19-month processing delay and later on the argument that federal law compels access for eligible institutions. That argument has now failed at every level that considered it.

What did the appellate courts decide?

In March, an appeals court denied Custodia's petition for a rehearing en banc, leaving standing the prior ruling that the Fed's approval decision is discretionary. Custodia petitioned the Supreme Court in July to take the case. Monday's cert denial ends the litigation; no merits opinion was issued.

The practical consequence is that no court has ordered the Fed to open its payment rails to a crypto-focused institution over staff objections. In plain terms: the Fed decides who gets in, and its reasons need not meet a statutory test.

Custodia did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

Is a 'skinny master account' the next battleground?

Attention has shifted to a proposal first floated by Fed Governor Christopher Waller for a "skinny master account" — a tailored, limited-purpose arrangement. The Fed requested public comments on the slimmed-down design last year. Under the proposal, the account would not earn interest on balances and would not permit access to the discount window, among other restrictions.

Comment letters split along predictable lines. Crypto advocates called the proposal overdue, while requesting revisions. Community banks countered that novel financial institutions do not operate under the same robust regulatory compliance regime and should not gain equivalent access.

Custodia had told the Supreme Court that a limited-purpose account would not suffice, in part because interest could not be earned on the account's closing balance, Bloomberg reported. The firm's objection, in short: a stripped account is not the account it sued for.

Where does crypto banking access stand now?

The legal landscape has already moved beyond Custodia's case. Crypto exchange Kraken's banking division became the first crypto company to obtain a master account in March — through approval, not litigation. That precedent suggests the operative question is no longer whether a crypto firm can hold a master account, but which business models clear the Fed's risk review.

Lawmakers have pushed back on the skinny-account concept, questioning the safety and soundness of the Fed's payment rails. The Fed, for its part, has said innovation may warrant a tailored approach that mitigates risk. The comment record and any final rulemaking will determine whether limited access becomes a real channel or a dead letter.

The takeaway: Custodia's defeat confirms Fed discretion in law, while Kraken's approval shows that discretion can cut both ways. The next definitive signal will come from the Fed's final decision on the skinny master account framework.

via The Block (Source)

More from Elena Vasquez

Elena Vasquez

Show full bio

Staff writer covering regulation, policy and their impact on crypto and web3 industry at Mempool Brief.

1,647 articles