5c64d3ee-1
S&P Cuts Tether's USDT Assessment to 'Weak' Over Reserve Risk
S&P cut USDT's stablecoin assessment to "5 (weak)" on Nov 26, 2025, flagging that Bitcoin, gold and corporate bonds now make up 24% of reserves against a 3.9% collateral buffer.

Outputs
S&P downgraded USDT from "4 (constrained)" to "5 (weak)" on November 26, 2025
Higher-risk assets (Bitcoin, gold, secured loans, corporate bonds) reached 24% of reserves as of September 30, 2025, up from 17% a year earlier
Bitcoin was about 5.6% of USDT in circulation against a 3.9% overcollateralization buffer
USDT circulation was roughly $184 billion at downgrade time, since trading between $175 billion and $180 billion
S&P rates Circle's USDC "strong," the opposite end of its stablecoin scale
S&P Global Ratings downgraded its stablecoin assessment of Tether's USDT to "5 (weak)" on November 26, 2025, citing riskier reserve composition and persistent disclosure gaps at the issuer of the world's largest dollar-pegged token.
The one-notch cut from "4 (constrained)" — a grade Tether had held since December 2023 — lands on the two metrics S&P weights most: what backs the token, and how much anyone outside the company can verify about it.
Tether rejected the report, arguing S&P leaned on an outdated framework that, in the company's telling, ignores USDT's resilience, its transparency efforts and a decade-long record of holding its peg. The company also notes most of its reserves sit in short-term US Treasuries and cash equivalents.
S&P's concern is with the minority slice, and that slice is growing.
What did S&P actually flag?
The core issue is reserve quality. The agency counted Bitcoin, gold, secured loans and corporate bonds as higher-risk holdings. Together they made up 24% of Tether's reserves as of September 30, 2025, up from 17% a year earlier.
Bitcoin is where the arithmetic gets uncomfortable. Per S&P's analysis:
- Bitcoin accounted for roughly 5.6% of USDT in circulation
- Tether's overcollateralization buffer — the cushion of excess reserves above what it owes holders — sat near 3.9%
That gap means a sharp fall in the Bitcoin portion of reserves could produce losses larger than the spare cushion can absorb. In that scenario, the assets backing USDT would be worth less than the tokens outstanding.
Disclosure was the second problem. S&P said it still cannot clearly see who custodies the reserves, who the counterparties are, or the exact makeup of the assets.
How does USDT compare on S&P's scale?
The agency's stablecoin assessment framework dates to 2023 and rates factors including asset quality and regulatory oversight to judge how likely a token is to hold its peg.
The comparison with Circle is hard to ignore. S&P gives USDC a "strong" assessment, placing the two biggest dollar stablecoins at opposite ends of the agency's scale.
Scale is the backdrop. USDT circulation stood at roughly $184 billion around the time of the downgrade and has since traded between $175 billion and $180 billion. Even after the cut, USDT kept trading near $1.
What does this change for Tether?
In the near term, not much operationally — the peg held and no redemptions event accompanied the note. The pressure is reputational and structural, because "weak" is now the label attached to the largest stablecoin by circulation at a moment when institutional due diligence increasingly runs through rating frameworks rather than marketing claims.
The number worth tracking is the Bitcoin-versus-buffer gap. If Tether shrinks its Bitcoin exposure or builds a bigger overcollateralization cushion, the most specific part of S&P's critique loses force. If Bitcoin keeps growing as a share of reserves while the buffer stays near 3.9%, the shortfall becomes harder to defend.
The next checkpoint is Tether's subsequent reserve attestation: whether the higher-risk share keeps climbing, and whether the company answers S&P's questions on custodians and counterparties, will determine whether this downgrade marks a floor or a step in a longer slide.
via spglobal.com (Original)
More from Marcus Bennett
Show full bio
Senior reporter covering money, funding and market shifts around crypto and web3 industry at Mempool Brief.
1,512 articles