a43be81e-f
Tether’s USDT remains at S&P’s lowest stability score of 5
S&P kept USDT’s stability score at 5 as riskier holdings rose to 28% of circulating supply, while Tether disputed the framework and KPMG’s audit remained unpublished.

Outputs
S&P Global Ratings’ Nov. 18 assessment kept USDT at 5, the lowest available “weak” score, unchanged from November 2025.
Higher-risk holdings equated to 28% of circulating USDT on Sept. 30, up from 24% a year earlier.
Tether reported approximately $191.5 billion in assets, $183.5 billion in liabilities and $7.95 billion in excess assets.
CNAD requires 70% of reserves to consist of assets that can be liquidated within 30 days.
KPMG issued an unqualified opinion on Tether’s 2025 accounts, but the audited statements and report remain unpublished.
S&P Global Ratings kept Tether’s USDT at a stability score of 5, labeled “weak” and the lowest available level, in its Nov. 18 Stablecoin Stability Assessment. The rating remained unchanged from November 2025 even as riskier assets grew to 28% of circulating USDT as of Sept. 30, from 24% a year earlier.
S&P classified these holdings as higher risk:
- Gold
- Bitcoin (BTC)
- Public equities
- Secured loans
- Corporate bonds
At 28%, the higher-risk share equaled more than one in every four units of circulating USDT. S&P warned: “A significant drop in the value of these assets could lead to USDT being undercollateralized.”
Why did S&P stop at the lowest score?
S&P identified further weaknesses but left the score at 5 because its framework cannot produce a lower rating. Tether rejected that judgment, telling Cointelegraph that the problem lay with S&P’s framework rather than its reserves. Tether invoked The Big Short, a film about the 2008 crisis, and cited the agency’s own history as evidence of the underlying problem.
At the initial 2025 downgrade, Tether CEO Paolo Ardoino wrote on X: “we wear your loathing with pride.” He presented past financial collapses as proof that traditional systems were broken.
Does Tether still show a reserve surplus?
Tether’s Sept. 30 reserve report, attested by BDO, showed approximately $191.5 billion in assets against $183.5 billion in liabilities. The difference left roughly $7.95 billion in excess assets. That reported surplus does not resolve S&P’s concerns because the agency focused on asset composition, segregation and the evidence available to verify the balances.
What does El Salvador’s reserve rule change?
In January 2025, Tether relocated to El Salvador. The National Commission of Digital Assets of El Salvador (CNAD), the regulator overseeing Tether there, requires 70% of reserves to consist of assets that can be liquidated within 30 days. That threshold equals seven of every 10 reserve units.
Tether called the framework broad, allowing relatively high-risk assets such as gold, BTC and loans to count toward the requirement.
CNAD also does not require Tether to segregate reserve assets, a safeguard regulators in the US and Europe expect. S&P found no publicly available information showing whether Tether segregates the assets, limiting its view of how reserves are insulated from broader corporate risks. A liquidity test alone therefore does not establish legal separation from the issuer.
Why does the KPMG audit not settle disclosure concerns?
In August 2026, KPMG confirmed that it had issued an unqualified opinion on Tether’s 2025 accounts, which the company described as its first full independent audit. Tether said the audit supported its financial statements. S&P said the company had not published the audited statements or the auditor’s report, limiting its ability to check the underlying information.
Tether’s reserve reports also do not name the custodians or counterparties that hold its assets. The company provides quarterly attestations, while other stablecoins generally report monthly. Publication of the audit would provide more evidence than an attestation, but the missing custodian and counterparty detail would still leave gaps in any assessment of control over assets.
Does a weak rating contradict USDT’s trading record?
No. S&P ended the Nov. 18 report by noting that Tether had maintained a good history of price stability, particularly over the last 12 months. The distinction matters: the score evaluates the resilience of reserves and oversight, while the observed record describes how closely the market price has tracked the dollar. Strong recent trading performance does not remove the structural risks S&P identified.
Tether also backed a Bolivian fintech bringing USDT payments to food-delivery and banking services, extending the token’s commercial reach even as S&P questioned the issuer’s reserve structure.
What does this change for USDT holders?
For institutions, payment processors and large holders, the practical implication is a higher diligence threshold. A stable peg and positive reported surplus do not answer whether reserves can be liquidated within 30 days, segregated from corporate liabilities or independently verified. The 28% higher-risk allocation therefore remains central to any assessment of USDT’s resilience.
Publication of KPMG’s audited statements and report is the next concrete checkpoint; a move by CNAD toward segregation or public custodian disclosure would be the market-structure change that could materially address S&P’s oversight concerns.
via spglobal.com (Original)
More from Nathan Brooks
Show full bio
Market editor covering money, funding and market shifts around crypto and web3 industry at Mempool Brief.
1,574 articles