55005bb9-c

ConfirmedStablecoins677 words3 min decode

S&P Keeps Tether’s USDT at Lowest Stability Level of 5

S&P Global Ratings left Tether’s USDT at stability level 5, citing higher-risk assets at 28% of circulation, up from 24% last year; Tether disputes the framework.

S&P Maintains Weak Stability Assessment for Tether’s USDT
WitnessS&P Maintains Weak Stability Assessment for Tether’s USDTgeralt / pixabay

Outputs

  1. S&P Global Ratings retained USDT at stability level 5, its lowest assessment.

  2. Higher-risk assets account for 28% of USDT circulation.

  3. The higher-risk share rose from 24% last year.

  4. Tether disputes the assessment, citing limitations in S&P’s evaluation framework.

By Elena Vasquez

S&P Global Ratings has kept Tether’s USDT at stability level 5, its lowest assessment, with higher-risk assets representing 28% of the token’s circulation. The figure, up from 24% last year, forms the central factual basis for the rating and leaves USDT’s collateralization under sustained scrutiny.

This is a ratings action, not an announced enforcement case: the report identifies no court filing, regulator action, seizure, fine or exploit tied to the decision. It also provides no publication date for the latest assessment, so it cannot establish which reserves or market conditions changed beyond the reported year-over-year rise in the higher-risk share.

Why did S&P retain the lowest assessment?

S&P characterizes level 5 as reflecting “significant concerns regarding the stablecoin’s collateralization.” On that assessment, the 28% allocation is the central reason for concern. In reader terms, the report places nearly 28 of every 100 USDT tokens in circulation in the higher-risk category, compared with nearly 24 a year earlier.

The increase is four percentage points, from roughly one-quarter of circulation to slightly more than one-quarter, not a 28% rise in the reported share. The report does not state whether the absolute quantity of higher-risk assets increased, stayed flat or declined. It also does not identify the assets, their issuers, maturities, jurisdictions, custody arrangements or valuation treatment.

Those omissions prevent an outside reader from testing whether the risk is concentrated, temporary or structural. The rating rests on a rising reported share, but the available material withholds the asset-level details needed to test it.

Why is Tether disputing the assessment?

Tether disputes the assessment and attributes it to “limitations in S&P’s evaluation framework.” That is a methodological challenge, not a denial that higher-risk assets represent 28% of USDT circulation. The distinction matters because disagreeing with the measurement does not provide a replacement assessment or reconcile the reported allocation.

The available report gives no detailed Tether rebuttal, revised collateral figures, response from S&P or endorsement of Tether’s position by an independent reviewer. It also does not say whether either side supplied transaction-level data or how S&P values the disputed holdings. As a result, the published facts leave the framework dispute unresolved.

The challenge targets the method, while the record does not resolve the 28% figure against an alternative calculation. Neither side has produced evidence that settles the other’s objection.

What does the rating mean for market confidence?

The decision leaves a public signal of elevated collateral concern attached to USDT despite Tether’s objection. It does not establish that USDT failed, breached a claim or lost dollar parity; the report records no default, redemption interruption or legal finding. The immediate business consequence is continued uncertainty over the quality of USDT’s collateral and the reliability of the rating process.

The report also places the decision against a crypto market showing mixed signals, with uneven momentum and sentiment leaving traders cautious about implications for stablecoin reliability. That context provides no causal evidence that the assessment changed trading, liquidity or institutional allocations. The report supplies no price or volume figures from which to infer such an effect.

The rating raises confidence risk without demonstrating a realized failure. Its practical significance depends on the undisclosed composition of the collateral, not on market speculation.

What needs to resolve the dispute?

Material resolution requires more than a methodological objection. Readers would need the identities and terms of the assets inside the 28%, a fuller account of S&P’s treatment and Tether’s specific criticisms, and any revised share for a later period. The current record includes none of those details, so no definitive conclusion about USDT’s collateral quality follows.

The next verifiable checkpoint is S&P’s next stability review or a fuller disclosure from either party. If neither occurs before the next review, the 28% figure and unresolved framework dispute remain the operative facts for market-confidence decisions; the report sets no revision deadline or enforcement timetable.

via cryptonews.net (Source)

More from Elena Vasquez

Elena Vasquez

Show full bio

Staff writer covering regulation, policy and their impact on crypto and web3 industry at Mempool Brief.

1,647 articles