46f9199a-d

ConfirmedStablecoins778 words4 min decode

S&P Keeps Tether's USDT at 'Constrained', Its Lowest Stability Grade

S&P Global Ratings held USDT at grade 5, 'constrained,' as high-risk assets reached 28% of circulation. Tether counters: 'the problem is S&P's framework, not our reserves.'

S&P Keeps Tether's USDT at Lowest Stability Rating on Higher Risk-Asset Exposure
WitnessS&P Keeps Tether's USDT at Lowest Stability Rating on Higher Risk-Asset ExposureWorldSpectrum / pixabay

Outputs

  1. S&P kept USDT at grade 5, 'constrained,' its lowest stability score, unchanged from November 2024.

  2. High-risk assets covered 28% of circulating USDT at end-September, up 4 percentage points year over year.

  3. Tether's BDO-attested report showed about $191.5B in assets, $183.5B in liabilities, a roughly $7.95B surplus.

  4. El Salvador's rules require 70% of reserves liquid within 30 days but allow gold, Bitcoin and loans, with no segregation mandate.

  5. Tether says it received a KPMG audit opinion for fiscal 2025, but the report has not been made public.

S&P Global Ratings has kept its stability assessment on Tether's dollar-pegged stablecoin USDT at the lowest available grade, citing a rising share of high-risk assets, weak reserve-protection arrangements and limited financial disclosure. The rating, published Nov. 18 and first reported by Cointelegraph, holds USDT at 5, or "constrained," unchanged from November last year.

The agency said it identified additional weaknesses since the previous assessment, but its framework has no category below "constrained." In plain terms, the worst grade on the scale is also the ceiling of what it can express.

What is driving the downgrade-in-place?

S&P classifies gold, Bitcoin, listed equities, secured loans and corporate bonds as high-risk assets. Those holdings accounted for 28% of USDT in circulation at the end of September, up 4 percentage points from a year earlier. The agency warned that a sharp decline in the value of those assets could leave USDT undercollateralized — meaning the reserves backing the token would fall short of the tokens outstanding.

For context, a four-point shift on a base the size of USDT's circulation represents billions of dollars moving into assets whose value can swing materially within days. The concentration question is therefore not academic; it is a solvency question under stress.

Takeaway: one in four dollars backing USDT now sits in assets S&P treats as risky, and that share is growing.

How did Tether respond?

Tether disputed the assessment in direct terms. "The problem is S&P's assessment framework, not our reserves," the company said, shifting the argument from the balance sheet to the methodology applied to it.

The company's end-September reserve report, released with an attestation from accounting firm BDO, listed about $191.5 billion in total assets against roughly $183.5 billion in total liabilities. That leaves excess assets over liabilities of about $7.95 billion — a buffer of just over 4% of liabilities. Tether will argue the buffer proves adequacy; skeptics will note that attestation is not audit, and that the figure is a snapshot, not a guarantee of resilience in a drawdown.

Takeaway: Tether shows an $8 billion surplus, but the number rests on quarterly attestations rather than continuous, public verification.

Why does El Salvador's rulebook matter?

Reserve regulation became a second point of contention. Tether relocated to El Salvador, and S&P said the country's rules require 70% of reserves to be held in assets that can be liquidated within 30 days. That sounds stringent. The agency noted, however, that the rules permit a broad range of holdings — including gold, Bitcoin and loans.

S&P also flagged the absence of any requirement to segregate reserves. Without segregation, the agency said, it is difficult to determine how well the assets backing USDT are protected from risks tied to Tether's other businesses. In plain words, the reserve pool may share a roof with riskier corporate activity, and outside observers cannot tell where the firewall sits.

Takeaway: the Salvadoran liquidity rule is looser than it first appears, and nothing forces Tether to ring-fence the assets.

Is disclosure the real bottleneck?

Tether said in August that it had received its first independent audit opinion from KPMG covering the full 2025 fiscal year — a step the company has long been pressed to take. S&P was unimpressed on one point: the audit report and financial statements have not been made public, so verification remains limited for third parties.

The agency also cited the lack of disclosure on reserve custodians and counterparties, and noted that reserve attestation reports arrive quarterly rather than monthly. Each gap extends the window during which outsiders cannot independently confirm what backs the largest stablecoin in circulation.

Takeaway: an audit that no one outside the company can read changes less than the announcement suggests.

What does S&P concede?

The agency did acknowledge the token's operational record. "Tether has maintained good price stability, particularly over the past 12 months," S&P said. The quote matters because it separates market performance — where USDT has held its peg — from structural resilience, which is what the rating measures. A peg that holds in calm conditions does not settle the question of what happens when 28% of reserves fall in value at once.

The disagreement now rests on process rather than arithmetic. Tether points to a growing surplus and a KPMG opinion; S&P points to unpublished statements, opaque custodianship and quarterly-only attestation. Whether the "constrained" grade moves will depend on what Tether chooses to publish — and the next reserve report, due quarterly, is the first date on which the argument can be tested against fresh numbers.

via en.bloomingbit.io (Source)

More from Elena Vasquez

Elena Vasquez

Show full bio

Staff writer covering regulation, policy and their impact on crypto and web3 industry at Mempool Brief.

1,576 articles