42f8036a-0
S&P downgrades Tether’s USDT peg assessment to weak
S&P Global Ratings cut Tether’s USDT peg assessment to “weak,” citing a 3.9% reserve buffer, rising Bitcoin exposure and disclosure gaps as circulation neared $184 billion.

Outputs
S&P downgraded USDT’s peg assessment to “weak” from “4 (constrained),” dated December 2023.
Bitcoin holdings equaled about 5.6% of USDT in circulation, versus a roughly 3.9% overcollateralization buffer.
The riskier asset group represented 24% of reserves on September 30, 2025, up from 17% a year earlier.
USDT circulation stood near $184 billion around the downgrade and later ranged from $175 billion to $180 billion.
S&P rates USDC “strong,” placing Circle’s token at the opposite end of its scale from USDT.
S&P Global Ratings downgraded Tether’s USDT peg assessment to “weak,” citing rising Bitcoin exposure, a roughly 3.9% overcollateralization buffer and continuing gaps in reserve disclosure. Tether disputed the action, saying S&P relied on an “outdated framework” that overlooked USDT’s resilience, transparency and decade-long record of holding its peg.
The downgrade came around the time USDT circulation stood at about $184 billion. Supply has since moved between $175 billion and $180 billion, while USDT has remained close to $1.
What changed in S&P’s assessment?
S&P’s previous score, dated December 2023, was “4 (constrained).” Its stablecoin assessment process also dates to 2023 and considers asset quality and regulatory oversight to judge how likely a token is to hold its peg.
Over roughly two years, USDT fell one notch while riskier holdings grew as a share of reserves. The label reflects less assessed capacity to absorb reserve shocks, not a documented failure of the peg. Takeaway: Tether now carries a weaker formal resilience rating while USDT still trades near $1.
How large is the reserve gap?
The assets grouped in S&P’s riskier category represented 24% of Tether’s reserves as of September 30, 2025, up from 17% a year earlier. S&P said Bitcoin holdings equaled about 5.6% of USDT in circulation, while the overcollateralization buffer was around 3.9%.
The buffer represents extra reserves above what Tether owes holders. S&P warned that a sharp fall in the Bitcoin slice could create losses larger than that cushion, leaving reserves worth less than the tokens outstanding.
The cited Bitcoin exposure was already larger than the reported headroom. That does not establish that reserves are currently deficient; it defines the stress case S&P considered insufficiently protected. Takeaway: Tether’s reported headroom is thinner than its cited Bitcoin exposure.
What is Tether’s defense?
Most of Tether’s reserves are in short-term US Treasuries and cash equivalents, according to the company. S&P’s objection concerns the smaller minority assigned to riskier assets, whose share has increased.
Tether also cites a decade-long peg record and what it describes as transparency. The cited response set no target for Bitcoin exposure, a buffer floor or a deadline for fuller reporting on custodians and counterparties. Takeaway: Tether challenged the methodology without publishing a measurable corrective plan in the material cited.
Why does disclosure matter?
S&P also cited continuing gaps in information about custodians, counterparties and the exact makeup of reserve assets. Those omissions leave the agency without a complete view of who holds the assets and what they consist of, beyond Tether’s broad descriptions.
The issue is separate from USDT’s quoted price. A token can remain close to $1 while observers cannot fully test the quality and composition of the assets backing it. Takeaway: Near-$1 trading has not resolved S&P’s questions about reserve transparency.
How does USDT compare with Circle’s USDC?
S&P has assigned USDC, issued by Circle, a “strong” assessment. That places the two biggest dollar stablecoins at opposite ends of the agency’s scale.
For Tether, the downgrade weakens its comparative standing within S&P’s framework, although the cited material identifies no institution that has changed USDT treatment because of the rating. Takeaway: USDT now sits at the weaker end of S&P’s stablecoin comparison.
What would resolve S&P’s critique?
S&P’s most specific warning has two measurable remedies: Tether can reduce Bitcoin exposure or build a larger overcollateralization cushion. Either move would narrow the gap between the cited 5.6% Bitcoin position and the 3.9% buffer.
Continued growth in Bitcoin’s reserve share with the buffer near 3.9% would weaken the position further. With no review date disclosed, the next S&P assessment is the practical checkpoint. Takeaway: Reserve composition and buffer size, not near-$1 trading, will show whether the critique loses force.
via cryptonews.net (Source)
More from Elena Vasquez
Show full bio
Staff writer covering regulation, policy and their impact on crypto and web3 industry at Mempool Brief.
1,576 articles